44 points | 2d ago | Discuss on Hacker News | Back to Radar
From the FAQ on https://hacktoberfest.com/ :
> Do I still submit pull requests to earn swag?
> Pull requests and merge requests will no longer count toward Hacktoberfest rewards. It’s easier than ever to submit low-effort spam PRs to projects, so we’re listening to maintainer feedback and no longer actively incentivizing PRs. That being said, we certainly still encourage you to work on open source and share your work with the world during Hacktoberfest. Our new format focuses on learning and building together while reducing the burden of low-effort contributions on maintainers.
I personally didn't know this, but I also don't submit PRs on github since a while ago.
One of the big changes right after that was offering free private repositories, most people complaining today would've probably not even used GitHub if there were only free public repositories.
Also, the old structure reflected their focus/encouragement of open source, something this change does even more to move away from.
At the same time, I don't view this as a huge issue, though it does make me wish it was easier to get activity details on forks so even if a repo is locked down it would let you see where PRs "went".
Open source projects are the main driver of this change, every popular open source projects gets a lot of drive by AI pull requests that waste maintainers’ time. Projects come up with their own way of blocking people (https://github.com/ghostty-org/ghostty/blob/main/.github/VOU...) but having this be a GitHub feature is a much easier option for most.
Another tab from first time/no pr approved yet users. Maintainers can treat it as spam box if they want.
Occasionally, users can flag them as useful and maintainers can then look at them.
Give a button to move from others to PR tab.
Don't consider count of PRs inside others in the main count.
... and there's an asymmetry there.-
Depends on your goal no? If your goal is to not accept random contributions or PRs, then being able to disable PRs completely, seems like the perfect approach? Up until this change (which happened almost a year ago, FWIW), it was impossible to just have a read-only mirror on GitHub that didn't get hit with drive-by PRs that just waste time, for example: https://github.com/videolan/dav1d/pulls?q=is%3Apr+state%3Acl...
I'm glad we can finally completely disable it, as it seems to just confuse people when you're not actually accepting PRs.
> I never thought I’d see the day where somebody who works at the DoD would spend their spare time
He didn't.
There needs to be public service announcements about responsible AI use. If we're going to boil the Earth and live in a world where a 64 GB DDR5 RAM kit that was $200 three years ago is now over $1000 then can we at least get the LLMs to generate code that's actually useful instead of circadian rhythm calculators.
I think it takes a certain type of person to join that department at this time, so make of that what you will. Certainly seems like they've "turned their life around", for better or worse.
Comments are loaded live from Hacker News and are not stored by Mid or Real.
soltanov 13h ago on HN