123 points | 7d ago | Discuss on Hacker News | Back to Radar
Arc takes a screenshot of the current page in a minimal chrome wrapper and includes your desktop wallpaper.
I noticed you have a file size comparison against common browsers but the one I’ve been using on the side is Search[1]; you browser is 18 MB, Search clocks in at 10.2 MB.
[1]: https://searchbrowser.appThat said, I fully agree on the importance of Firefox. Avoiding Webkit/Blink monoculture is crucial.
Last time I used Chromium it rendered my entire desktop unusable after a reboot. I had to spend a while tracking the issue, only to find out it somehow messed up the font cache, which made a lot of other programs crash.
Safari, I have no personal experience with. Technically, I think all of the major browsers are comparable. It’s the care for privacy, freedom, and the open web which make Firefox the obvious choice, in spite of Mozilla’s recent direction.
https://github.com/zen-browser/desktop/issues/5947 is this what you're referring to?
If it's the parent I don't understand what fears it's stoking.
If it's mine, I still don't understand what fears it's stoking. And who are you asking regarding bothering with my 'low effort' comment? Yourself? In which case why are you bothering? Or me? In which case are you asking for a source?
I am saying this because I hate having to write those conditions everywhere in my extension code to support different browsers, it’s error prone, and time taking. Now we have AI to do it and test it but earlier it was all me.
Chrome (and Chromium-based) browsers are basically DOA now, and no reason to daily driver them if they can't implement a simple feature like this.
Like, I'm surprised anyone takes Chrome seriously at all after Google was told to not misuse their monopoly position as the world's largest ad company and remove the ability for the world's most popular ad blocker and security extension to work, and then did it anyways.
... and then promptly bullied all Chromium-based browsers to merge the Manifest V2 removal patches.
Talking about Manifest v3 is hypocticial when Firefox basically did the same thing to sidebar extensions. Tree Style Tabs had to fight for its extension APIs when they switched to Web Extensions (or it might have been Quantum?). Not to mention that they made userChrome disabled by default so TST/Sideberry users like me have to do a bunch of shenanigans in about:config that they might randomly feel like removing one day.
Enroll in the beta, or wait a couple of weeks for the release.
This feels so close to that, well done!
As a hardcore Arc user, my take away is I'm not trusting anything that has significant human effort and funding behind it. I don't have the time - nor interest - to spare to move browsers constantly so I can only choose to invest in something with structure behind it.
While great things can come from a solo developer, in this day and age it's not the mark of a well-engineered product it once was, in my eyes at least. I'm really hoping that a community springs up around one strong contender and it matures into something that can be trusted over many years to come.
Something worth mentioning is that till this far, I samehow think Zigzag is suprisingly the best of all of them in terms of stability, coherence of the design, and sheer performance. It is really snappy, it doesn't have the overkill designs of the Arc (like the beautiful 3D opening of a folder for example) but it is more coherent than almost all the other versions I'm seening. But I hope I can find one even closer to Arc. Thanks again.
Someone mentioned the heavy usage of Claude, but for me the concern is another one. It's about the sustainability of the project and if this is just going to be discontinued like what happened to Arc.
As a user that needs to change his browser, I would understand what's going to be the future direction of this and if it can be economically viable for you to continue to work on the project. And just because it's open it doesn't mean that someone is going to take over
Hello! Going by the comments, you're getting the classic HN welcome :D
Awesome start wth Zigzag. I feel like browsers are ripe for innovation beyond Arc too. E.g.:
- What does it mean to manage tabs & bookmarks in an agentic age?
- What would a start page look like if an agent can fetch anything from anywhere?
- What do projects and history look like when you can let Claude rip on visualizations and exploration to track tasks over time, not just by window or grouping?
Just some food for thought! :)
I remember an experimental browser that was released a bunch of years ago, I think it was by a university professor and their students. Its primary feature was a visual layout that showed history as sort of a storyboard of which pages led to each successive page. It was a neat concept. I was only aware of a single release and I don't remember the name, but I'd peg its ship date as around the age of Digg though I more likely saw it on Slashdot.
1. Anyone remember that? 2. Maybe we'll see something useful like that again. I hope so.
It feels like I’m one compromised plug-in update away from getting rolled…
Otherwise really digging it!
I don't mean to be mean, and I'm not saying you're wrong - but this is what every vibe-coder says. Likely because Claude is constantly saying stuff like this.
I used firefox for a while but switched back because some sites didn't or rather some plugins caused issues with sites. The only thing I miss from firefox is how it managed containers and pinning websites to containers. Do recommend looking at that feature.
Comments are loaded live from Hacker News and are not stored by Mid or Real.
ma101an 6d ago on HN
Really I cannot overstate how fast/responsive it is. So smooth, no jank (I have 16GB M4 Air, when using Arc I can definitely see a small jank when opening & closing sidebar or resizing sidebar, swapping across spaces...) which I don't see at all in Zigzag
Also, I like how I can use chrome extensions here. Even though it's not 100% compatible, I can use ones that I have in my chromium browrser: ublock origin, unhook, video-speed-controller etc...
Some of the things I missed in safari are here, which I love: The reader mode & automatic dark mode support (removes need for me to use an extension for these "features")
overall idk if this is made with 100% AI or made by someone who actually have lot of knowledge and experience with building browsers, eitherways, from end user perspective, I love how its like Arc, but faster & uses safari engine (so its lightweight in MacOS)
ZigaoWang (author) 6d ago on HN
someguyiguess 4d ago on HN
Personability 4d ago on HN
ZigaoWang (author) 3d ago on HN