904 points | 5d ago | Discuss on Hacker News | Back to Radar
When I eventually buy a house with my own garage, I'm totally adding the garage door to Apple Home so that I can operate it with my voice while inside my helmet on my motorcycle, and not have to take my gloves off and get the remote control out. I hadn't thought of that possibility.
Another option: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d3rfaCfImwE :D
I also have a nodered automation setup that sends a push notification if the garage door is open for more than 30 minutes, so I don’t accidentally leave the garage open overnight. Works great.
I will sell/replace/throw every device if I see a ad in the ecosystem. Almost every IOT manufacturer does this crap so it gets more difficult. Moving the device to Home Assistant helps a little.
Ecobee you're next, and I hope you go down in flames having such crap software.
Also would be nice to have a law making ads and payment mutually exclusive. Otherwise the future is one where all products evolve to have both.
The "free market" cannot solve this in a world where products can be (and are) rugpulled to have ads anytime.
Likewise for online content. Hello, New York Times. Et al.
Today's front page screenshot 3 minutes ago:
What's really needed is system-wide notification channels, a hard requirement on app developers that marketing notifications go into the marketing channel, per-channel notification permissions, and a global off-switch for marketing channel notifications.
Apple needs to break this shitty business model. There's no incentive for Apple to keep allowing it.
> Don't use notifications for cross-promotion or advertising of another product, as this is strictly prohibited by the Play Store.
> Notification channels are defined according to best practices, rather than serving all notifications from one channel.
I was surprised by the first one as it does feel fairly common, though in my experience apps that do almost always have them grouped in a marketing category so it's easy to avoid after the first one.
https://developer.android.com/docs/quality-guidelines/core-a...
https://www.usps.com/business/informed-delivery.htm (Interactive Campaign Guide PDF https://www.usps.com/business/pdf/informed-delivery-interact... )
If they’re just spamming, then the opt out pre-screen won’t apply, which is unfortunate ( https://www.optoutprescreen.com/form - request no junk mail there)
This is why I don't let DoorDash send notifications. I just have to watch the app for our delivery, bc if I let them ping me it's a nonstop stream of advertising.
I bought a TV. I don't want to see ads displayed on it.
"it's gotten inside the code! run!"
It’s disturbing opening Tuya, to control the fan, only to often have to scroll past a big ad for Temu dildos and sex toys!
Nothing against dildos and sex toys but I don’t want to see them to use my ceiling fan and the ad profiling must be pretty terrible for a middle aged bloke with no browsing history of dildos and sex toys, trying to turn a fan on, not the misses.
Luckily I can mostly use the home assistant integration but still need to use Tuya for the sleep timer functionality.
Also waiting for the day the smart control stops working as the app shustdown. Specifically purchased the fan as it’s a dc fan with wall controller and smart controls was supplemental to that so not the end of the world but would it be if I purchased it for the smart controls was.
I looked around for some kind of device that would close it automatically, which apparently doesn't exist -- with good reason, honestly. What I found was a weird little IoT box that functioned as a garage door opener, and which I could configure with an app on my phone to yell at us (via notifications) if we left the door open for more than 5 minutes.
An unsought side benefit that nevertheless became handy was that we could now control the garage door with our phones.
That app was, initially, pretty straightforward and clean -- but over time, fucking ADS crept in. I was about ready to shift platforms to avoid that crap when we moved across the country. We lived in our new place first in a rental while we house-hunted, so I did nothing there, but I absolutely planned to find an ad-free owner-respecting platform for my garage needs in the new house.
Except, well, the house we bought had (has) a pretty dang new opener, and it's delightfully almost-silent, and it has the MyQ stuff built in already. So I'm right back where I started, cursing these craven weasels every time I use the app to get into the garage.
Somewhat ironically, though, our need for this tool has flipped. Now we live in a very secure neighborhood -- kids leave their bikes on their front lawns, etc -- so the "yell at me if I leave it open" function isn't as important. OTOH, since I haven't been able to find a suitable garage door opener that will mount cleanly on my motorcycles, using the phone to get into the garage has become the default.
Chamberlain has auto closing built in to some of the regular wall controls. Ben using them for years.
I picked up the ratgdo to solve this exact problem, but discovered that it can't detect the garage door state without upgrading the "button" / "control panel" on the wall to one that actually communicates with the opener rather than just basic open/close functions. The recommend button is the 889LM, which, get this, has a close delay function. AKA you open it, and it automatically closes it within a set delay after people stop walking through the safety beam.
So, while I have the HA integration now via the ratgdo, the function I wanted it for is handled automatically.
the day they interrupt me with ads in addition to paying will be the day I stop paying
Yep, it feels off because this was a desperate attempt to duplicate the experience of the excellent Sponsorblock[1] extension after users started asking Google the very logical question of why free users with Adblock+Sponsorblock were having a much better experience than paying YT Premium subscribers.
Honestly even with premium, this makes a ton of sense than Google's implementation as its categories cover a lot more. Data's crowdsourced and I've probably come across maybe <100 videos in my ~4 years+ of using it that don't have segments marked, and it's a single keystroke to mark beginning and end of segments to report them. My stats:
> You've saved people from 24,660 segments ( 18d 21h 16 minutes of their lives )
[1]: https://sponsor.ajay.app/ for many browsers including Firefox, Chromium, and Safari
Except they absolutely can as proved by community extensions which do exactly that.
Creators are required to disclose those ads for various legal reasons (e.g. if they want their video to be available in EU). Youtube could simply require to properly mark that segment (maybe it does that already) and skip it. So if I pay for no ads I see no ads. The "ovious reasons" would then be limited to illegal ads which users could report as such. Hell, make it optional or even per-channel setting.
* Youtube Featured - these are ads, you can close them. They don't play during the video, but they show up in the UI
* Youtube Featured Games - these are ads and show up in the browse UI
* Sponsored product links - show up during the video -- these are ads
* Youtube Preview - These are ads for shows by other channels, and they also show up in the UI while browsing, not while playing videos. But they are ads. Ads for shows on other networks that you can subscribe to through Youtube (extra fee)
Just because it's not a pre-roll video ad doesn't mean it's not an ad. Also, Youtube/Google is still harvesting all your browsing and viewing history and likely using that for targeted advertising on other google properties.> Sponsored product links
What can youtube do about this, it's channel/user decision, not them.
Oh no. They were on my "next up" list when my Nests inevitably get killed by Google. At least with the Nests, I use a Starling Hub[1] so that I don't have to have Google's shitty app on my phone and can just use HomeKit.
What's the best HomeKit thermostat now?
[1] https://www.starlinghome.io RIP, thank you shitty US government orange menace.
One thing that has actually made me really happy with the ecobee, is beestat.io, which is a website that will attach to your cloud account via API and offers some nice visualizations for your thermostat data. I don't use the ecobee website directly for anything, so maybe that's the crap software he's referring to.
Probably the upcoming "Apple Home Collection" Thermostats [1] as I'm guessing they will be tightly managed by Apple. We'll see with reviews though.
https://www.apple.com/shop/home/accessories/smart-home-acces...
The best approach seems to be to only buy devices with official HomeKit support, and pray that Apple doesn't start putting ads in the Home app.
No, the best approach is to buy devices that run open firmware and play well with Home Assistant. Anything closed source and controlled by a corporation is subject to changes to terms and conditions sooner or later, and will collect telemetry and do other nasty things to users.
Not it doesn't, esp32 is just mcu, with no one RE the device, there is no custom firmware for it.
doesn't matter. you have already paid for the device. at this point you are worthless to the company. they might maybe squeeze another few bucks from you by spamming in the notitications.
I've learned my lesson from a pile of e-waste by manufacturers who stopped updating their apps and killed their cloud services.
One of these days I'm just going to put in a Z-Wave Honeywell thermostat and be done with the Ecobee shenanigans.
I got a Raspberry Pi, added a camera, pointed the camera at my man door then added the following features
- Push notifications if garage door or man door were left open more than 10 minutes or opened between 10:00PM and 6:00AM
- Camera takes photos every second while the man door is opened or motion detected, uploaded to my NAS
- Door open/close control via buttons or voice command
Was a fun little project. I abandoned it when I moved to a house with door openers which run off the myQ app. I haven't had the ad issues OP has (yet) so I've not been motivated to rebuild a custom solution.
Using a pre-certified module doesn't let you bypass certification.
A few weeks ago, I noticed my Apollo-1 Air quality sensor was seeing some strange behavior in the basement. Home Assistant showed an unexplained temperature spike and humidity drop a little before 1am.
I managed to figure out from other sensors that nothing was actually awry (no spikes in draw of nearby devices, no telltale gas signatures of the water heater kicking on, no motion or CO2 indicating human or other large animal presence). Was the board malfunctioning? Fortunately the device has an internal temperature sensor and an ambient sensor which are separate. Logging confirms the temperature spike originated on the board, probably from the WiFi chip.
But, why?
It turns out, after inspecting the signal a bit more, than the MyQ was broadcasting so loudly between the WiFi and BLE, screaming for someone to talk to it, that my air sensor was having to increase its power to still be able to communicate over all the noise. Switching to a different channel for the crappy old downstairs AP fixed it, but still, c'mon!
I'm a little wary of connecting any sort of ingress/egress to my home to the network at all, even locally, but an honest appraisal of the basement is that smashing a window is probably a much bigger threat model than hacking the door opener. Or in other words, https://xkcd.com/538/
For the garage door opener, I haven't actually gone in to see if I can completely turn off the WiFi/BLE capabilities. If I can't, I'm still only going to allow control through the relay, but I'm considering putting the receptacle itself on a controller too so it only gets power when an open/close request is received. That'll break the manual button control, though, so I'll have to also add a new button that isn't actually directly connected but instead triggers the power-up request prior to the open request... it's a good thing I like building Rube Goldberg machines.
Since the code was put in a "best-effort basis" for future updates, it's gone from version 2.2 to 2.2.6 with numerous fixes. Most notable was software-configurable "debounce" functionality which finally solved my problem with the door tripping the magnetic reed switches several times quickly when the door comes to a stop and confusing the board about its current up/down status.
I bring it up because I have tremendous enthusiasm for people who take an idea, a cheap microcontroller, and put together a solution for people who prefer to stick with older, simple appliances but still want some sort of smart functionality. People who "make cool stuff and put it on the internet." That the creator disclosed that he's putting his focus on the newer boards and will maintain/fix issues with the older ones on a "best-effort" and then actually does it... it's fantastic. Because of this continued support and fixes, I can't recommend Ratgdo boards enough.
I wonder if someone will try to use AI to optimize the 8266 version to better handle RAM etc.
I also hate the amount of ads the myQ app has, like it's pretty much nothing but ads (and reporting this to the Play Store does nothing).
Currently, my garage door opener is connected to my WiFi (on its own "IoT VLAN") because I once had to use myQ to open my garage whilst away to let my friend into the house.
Normally, I just use a "normal" garage door opener remote (and my car's built-in HomeLink buttons).
I need your business notifications, I do not need or approve of your advertising/product updates.
For my mobile OS, all notifications look the same. "AI priority" is the only attempt at this but I don't need AI priority if I have a very tight-knit circle of apps that can send notifications.
Then one important app sends me spam and I turn it off immediately.
i've been meaning set up a dedicated domain/website just to collect complaints about this company's behavior, alternatives, workarounds for their failures like the one posted here recently [1], and importantly, laws. we need laws.
mentioned already in these comments: granular control over notifications between marketing & functional, and no circumvention by intermingling the two. home automation devices may be allowed to traverse wans to offer remote control for non-vpn/sd-wan users, but should not have their core functionality _or_ initial setup depend on an internet connection.
finally, locked devices produced by companies over a some market cap or another and their subsidiaries should be required to offer a bootloader for user/open firmware after some reasonable period of time to mitigate some of the mountains of ewaste we are producing with this stuff.
I have a zero tolerance policy for spam - notification permissions get taken away on the first offense, emails get marked as spam. I've had the ratgdo on eternal to-do list for a while, so this post speaks to me.
I use NextDNS, which allows me to block ads (including a lot of mobile ads) at the DNS level.
I disabled all notifications for myQ.
And I configured the garage door to auto-close at 9pm.
0: https://www.macrumors.com/2025/06/24/apple-wallet-notificati...
What OP is asking for is closer to Matter / Zigbee / Z-Wave, a protocol in which any hub can control any device: And things are getting closer to a standard with these!
That is, as long as device manufacturers actually use them and follow the specs
What I'm suggesting is regulation that would require hardware makers to e.g. use something like Zigbee for underlying communication in a standard manner. This would guarantee you're able to use any IoT/smart devices you buy with Home Assistant (or any other system implementing the protocols) if you so wish.
There may be some licensing or something else that makes it not an “open protocol” but I couldn’t be happier with my Z-wave and Zigbee devices. I’ve never seen a push notification from many of them because they don’t have access to the Internet. The manufacturers can go out of business and I wouldn’t notice or care.
Pair that with something like home assistant, and you have perfection (in my eyes).
It's a garage door opener it has two modes, opening and closing. The fact that they have an app you have to sign in to and provide your email to and they are actively stopping integration with the likes of Home assistant to make you use their horrible app is just absurd.
I shouldn't be getting spam because my garage door is selling my private data.
For anyone wondering, get a Genie instead. I have one for over a decade and it works great.
Which means I'm going to be super sad if I ever need to put in new openers, I guess. I'll pay to keep these alive as long as I can, if they ever start to give me problems.
I am of the persuasion that a smart home should never require whipping out your phone, but I have not been able to brush away all occurrences yet. But the Hue app always motivates me to either do things via Home Assistant (including just coupling the bulb directly using ZigBee) or get a switch ASAP.
Yes Signify (former Philips), you got an ad in my face, congrats, but you also got me super annoyed and I'll be on the lookout for alternatives.
But I control rooms with many lights with 1 switch, dim them, control other areas with motion sensors, and some go on and off automatically. Ah well, not really a requirement for a happy life, I know... Whereas the ad slap is a real drain...
I did make most of the things here in the house myself and saved a lot of work by not having to make all those switching wires in the walls :)
It's a hard requirement for all my automation, in fact. Every single thing fails back to working precisely the same way it would without any smart features. Door locks, lights, all of it.
So there's some grumbling when the automation fails for any reason, but that grumbling is not because it suddenly got harder than necessary, but just that it went back to the default level of inconvenience that you are used to.
It does make home assistant quite important all of a sudden, now it can be off and most things still work... Hue is quite appliance-like in that sense.
I share the concern on HomeAssistant going down, but it hasn't happened to me yet whereas I have gotten badly timed surprise mandatory updates from Philips before. And HA is easier to backup.
https://www.home-assistant.io/blog/2026/11/04/release-202611...
Granted, this has happened 1 or 2 times in 8 years or so (and I've since added a UPS)? And if the bridge breaks were equally sol.
I recently installed a Chaimberlain garage door opener in a location that required three buttons inside the garage. They limit the buttons in software, so that each garage door opener can have only two at any given time!
After some tinkering, I discovered that the Chaimberlain buttons transmit their signal wirelessly these days, even when "wired" to the garage door opener... the wires only provide power. So...
I worked around the problem by placing a dab of solder on one of their security+ 3.0 buttons so that it is always "pressed." Then I wired up the three old school garage door momentary switches to send power to it. When pressed, they power up the Chaimberlain button, which then sends a wireless signal to open the door.
TBQH I used myQ to link it to HomeKit and literally haven't once opened that app since. Sounds like I should keep that going if at all possible.
It’s been great but I know I’m on borrowed time.
If the garage door breaks I’m 100% NOT replacing it with another chamberlain. Good job guys
FYI, the openers built into cars are very adaptable - my work has old school DIP-switch security on the garage gates, and it learned that just fine.
Home Assistant integration is flawless. There is esphome firmware for the ratgdo (instructions in their official docs) and if you're familiar with esphome, you know how well it works with HA. Very low latency and 100% local.
It also allows me to setup useful automations like locking all remotes at night so if someone breaks in my car, they can't hit the button to open the garage.
..before they stop allowing this, especially after IPO
But fortunately those two models are good enough to do stuff like this.
The future of reverse engineering is abliterated models running on your own or rented hardware.
It's also important to understand they are backed by a private equity firm spending a lot money buying up the other leading garage door companies. This isn't just a preference to keep people in their cloud if possible, it's a long-term plan to corner the market and distribution channels and then start locking all remote features behind $ubscription pay walls and all their non-Chamberlain brands will do it too.
They've already shown they're willing to increase BOM costs on stuff that only locks out local-only use.
Who's going to be first to test if the laws actually work?
Chamberlain and liftMaster are the same.
I don't know what the other two you mentioned.
One of these:
https://www.insteon.com/products/io-module-garage-door-contr...
...with the contact closure wires soldered to the button of a car remote.
Controlled by Universal Devices isy994i/eisy.
I do have to change the battery in the remote every five to six years or so.
(That position will change when wireless charging of low-powered devices becomes more widely available.)
The ratgdo encoder is a precision sensor that tracks your garage door's physical state. It enables your ratgdo control board to detect the door's exact position and direction of travel in real time—whether it's fully open, closed, or anywhere in between.
I feel dumb implementing my own "sliding door open/closed/in-between" sensor with 2 cheap zigbee door sensors and some logic in Home AssistantMaybe call it "How I learned to stop worrying and love the garage door opener" or "HILTS-WALT-GDO" for that extra eye-rollingness.
do not buy chamberlain ever.
I ended up purchasing a Matter device which physically presses the button on a factory remote [1]. Ridiculous that such a solution needs to exist.
[1] https://www.thirdreality.com/products/smart-garage-door-open...
It was great during the trial as the garage door just opens and closes as you drive. I almost paid as $3/month isn’t much but out of principle I won’t. I curse myq every time I push the button manually.
What a mess. I regret letting the installer use this opener. I was hoping i could just figure out what the Android app, or my Tesla does, to open the door and replicate that. Turns out I cant.
I may even get rid of the magnetic sensor in favor of a local VLM that reads the garage security camera that I already have installed. One less thing to change batteries on every 6 months.
The notification marketing spam is really bad right now. I can literally turn off every marketing toggle in the Uber app (buried as it is), save it, then swipe out of those settings, then back in, and the notifications are all enabled again. Same goes for a lot of other apps, like the Dominos pizza app.
It’s gotten to the point where I just install the app, use it to order a pizza or a ride, the. uninstall the offending app (though sometimes I still get ghost notifications!)
But for apps like those for garage doors, that’s not a viable strategy.
I know why these notifications happen. The open rate ranges from 5-20% (though up to half of these can be accidental, but at least you got them back into the app, right).
But it really feels like an intrusion on the iOS and Android in ways that can compromise usage of the phone. It seems like at least Apple used to care about this and maintain UX standards but it seems like that has gone out the window.
For people who can’t jury rig a solution to their garage door opener, what can they do?
And for stuff like Domino's, why do you need notifications? Just turn off all its notifications at the Android level.
If they can't be bothered to ring the doorbell and wait for me, as was the norm for pizza delivery drivers since forever, they won't get a tip.
Now if you mean 3rd party delivery for stuff that isn't pizza, that's a different story. At some level, though, I'm just not sympathetic. Delivery is not cheap, and has all kinds of problems, including all the ones highlighted in this thread. If you think dealing with all of this (including notification issues) is worth the hassle, by all means, accept your reality. I just go to the restaurant and pick up myself.
(We live above the ground floor in a multi-unit building. This brilliant life hack may not be applicable in all situations.)
With BuzzKill, you can have rules like "Block all messages except those that contain <text>". This way, you can still get notifications related to orders/delivery.
Me to pizza pizza in August (same issue is in the dominos app fyi).
> App should have options to disable marketing push notifications.
Reply:
> Good evening,
> Thank you for the feedback. you are correct you can turn off all notifications, however it won't let you just turn off marketing.
> Regards,
> <Name>
I don't think the product folks even know about it.
Also (very important) the app never knows any of this happened.
How is this a superpower though? It has something to do with them saying "I won't say how to reproduce this here."
Are the economics such that it's just not possible to start a company making decent, servicable products?
Largely, yes. If you make a washing machine that lasts 20 years, you sell one washing machine. If you make one that lasts just beyond its warranty period, you might lose that customer for a minute, but there are so few actual manufacturers to pick from that you soon run out.
The negative externalities are not currently priced into cheap shit.
There are some products that fit, see the Buy It For Life movement, but they tend to be very low-tech, like cast-iron pans.
Oh you absolutely can, the problem is that the siren's lure of monthly recurring revenue is far too strong.
Honestly probably not economically serviceable by me either, but I enjoy taking stuff apart, so...
For food delivery, the gig workers usually knock on the door, or ring the doorbell. If they don’t, hunger will remind me to check the app anyways.
I have LG washtower thinQ enabled, and the phone app was maybe worse than the garage door opener app. But, at least, the app can be deleted, and the data endpoints are still emitting sensor data enough for home assistant to pick it up. No spam because no app. I get an email when the washer/dryer finishes, I know to plop wet clothes into the dryer, and that works great. That's a good experience. Getting phone ads for soap at 2am is not a good experience.
The reason ads come at us from every fucking angle of life is because they work. That’s unacceptable, imo.
They don’t work on me, they don’t work on you, so who the fuck do they work on?
The answer: most people. And that’s why they keep showing them.
All of the anti-patterns we all hate only perpetuate because they work.
We really need to figure out a way to educate people better so that these practices stop working. And I’ve no clue how to do that (tried with my parents, failed miserably in a cloud of “this is too confusing I don’t care.”)
I've never understood how technologists, product managers, and marketing people can sit in the same conference room and collectively decide, "Hey, let's start sending unsolicited marketing push notifications to our users, and while we're at it, we can make another $1,000 a month by stuffing Google Ads into the app."
And then everyone around the table nods their heads and says, "Great idea, let's do it!"
If I were in that room, I'd be throwing chairs. I'd be so vehemently opposed to this kind of garbage that the meeting would come to a screeching halt.
I genuinely cannot comprehend the decision-making process that leads an entire room of supposedly intelligent people to agree that deliberately degrading the user experience for a few extra dollars is a good business decision. These are not freemium products - these customers paid for these products!!
Sure. Then they'd call security, and reschedule the meeting to the next day. The next day, everyone would say "Great idea, let's do it!"
The problem is the incentives created by the pervasive digital backdoors products now ship with (for decades now). Consumers just aren't that forward thinking or self actualizing (or they would have never adopted these products in the first place!). Once one company does it and gets away with it, then all the rest follow.
The only thing that is really going to fix it is laws, and good luck with that with our corpo-pwned government. If you sold someone a device that you had added retained remoted access to, and then used it to harm them and benefit yourself, you'd be facing CFAA charges - even if you slipped some legalese nastygram in the box along with it. But when a corpo does the same thing, it's just a "profitable business practice".
It’s simple though. They have market power - or so they think - and they are wielding it.
Uber, DoorDash, and a litany of other enshittified products where sometimes you have to fight the app’s banners and popups to even get to the checkout.
Imagine running a store where when someone is approaching the checkout with an item they would like to buy, a bunch of others jump in front of them to sell them other things, as if the goal is to prevent this person from getting to the register and pay.
Amazon, despite all its faults and counterfeit products and other monopolistic practices, has the best checkout.
"Sound good, let add ads"
Chamberlain used to have a HomeBridge, that connected to HomeKit, device that would sit in your garage and sit on your wifi network. It would pair with the opener similar to how a normal wall-mounted garage door panel would. Not only was this setup a little clunky, it was slow. The Siri -> Door open process would often take 5-10 seconds. This wasn't great, but it worked. Sort of.
Then, they did two things that made my blood boil: they discontinued support for it and prevented you from repairing the device with their myQ app, then started using notification for ads.
When I was about to sink an unhealthy amount of time into a garage door opener, ratgdo came in and rescued me. Not only was it simple to install but it was lightning fast. On the same network, it started opening and closing the door the second the Siri command went off. I can only assume that the previous system used to do roundtrips to Chamberlain and the connection wasn't the fastest in the garage.
Ratgdo man, if you read this you have my thanks (and my money, obviously.)
do not buy chamberlain ever.
Uses your existing wiring, etc.
https://www.uxmatters.com/mt/archives/2009/10/images/figure_...
- does not have a subscription fee
- does not sell data
- does not have ads or remarket
- follows basic cyber security hygiene
- is simple to set up (thinking of my parents)
- interacts purely through standard protocols
I have long delayed wiring my home with IoT devices, but would be interested in doing so if I could have some basic assurances about the experience of using it being pleasant and safe. Almost everybody that I know who has invested heavily in IoT has had to treat it like a side project to avoid the various pitfalls.
> 4.5.4 Push Notifications must not be required for the app to function, and should not be used to send sensitive personal or confidential information. Push Notifications should not be used for promotions or direct marketing purposes unless customers have explicitly opted in to receive them via consent language displayed in your app’s UI, and you provide a method in your app for a user to opt out from receiving such messages. Abuse of these services may result in revocation of your privileges.
Depending on your electrical code however, you might need to hire an electrician for the job.
Technically it is against app store review guidelines to use push notifications for ads, unless the user has specifically opted in. I'm guessing it's difficult to catch during app review, or reviewers don't care.
> 4.5.4 Push Notifications must not be required for the app to function, and should not be used to send sensitive personal or confidential information. Push Notifications should not be used for promotions or direct marketing purposes unless customers have explicitly opted in to receive them via consent language displayed in your app’s UI, and you provide a method in your app for a user to opt out from receiving such messages. Abuse of these services may result in revocation of your privileges.
https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/#:~:...
There is definitely no way to opt-in our opt-out in Feit or Arlo. My guess is the same with all these other apps.
You can still find a few "non-smart" garage door openers, for now. They tend to be the lowest tier models, who knows if enough people will keep buying them that manufacturers will keep offering them. And worst case, you can just open the door manually. They are spring assisted and not very heavy. For my entire childhood I was the garage door opener whenever I was going somewhere in the car with my parents.
Even worse with cars, there's basically no non-smart cars left and they're all surveillance boxes on wheels with tons of IoT stuff installed whether you want it or not.
it should be illegal for someone who had a good idea once to be allowed to leave that good idea in the hands of others
sell it as a loss leader and make the money up on ads / revenue. Once you install something (physically), it's almost not worth it to uninstall it. Expect this with all "smart" iot devices
A MyQ costs 50$ (sometimes down to 19.99 on sale), there's a reason for that.
I assume this is because commercial users have control stations that use dry contacts, and the modern crap is simply a nonstarter.
And if everyone's doing it what choice do you have? If someone actually starts selling these devices there's a good chance the manufacturer will sue for patent infringement, DCMA reverse engineering or some other guff.
I bought a house that came with a Chamberlain garage door opener. At $20 I figured I would try the MyQ device to see if it's as bad as people say. It is that bad.
I bought the Tailwind device and it is exactly what I wanted. I can tell Google to open/close the door. My only complaint is that Google makes me tell it a code to open, but you can put it in one voice prompt "hey google open the garage door with code NNNN".
I wouldn't consider it prudent to replace one cloud-dependent service for another. Fool me once and all that.
do not buy chamberlain ever.
I'm keeping it simple now, HomeKit or bust for the smart home.
The way around it is to solder onto the contacts of their proprietary buttons.
Anyone have updates on that situation?
I don't know why we approach everything like this as a challenge. Certainly, we can make this work. Technically there's nothing stopping us from integrating anything with anything else. But, what is the cost of maintaining this? How many others in your household are into your hobby as much as you are?
This hack could be monetised at this step, by allowing adverts at this step. This would complete the (tech) circle of life nicely.
Although it only triggers the button. So no information on whether it is opened or closed.
Of course the flipside is that if your thing depends on an app you need ongoing maintenance, but if you've got an advertising-riddled app spamming notifications it seems like the prophylactic is indistinguishable from the disease it prevents.
Meanwhile there are Zigbee solutions you can order from Aliexpress for like ten bucks, and those only need to be wired into your existing opener, so install consists of an hours's worth of fiddling with wires.
On Quora there has been a slew of spammers trying to sell garage door openers. It's probably just a scam, but it seems a pretty niche scam.
For the OP, do you really need to fire off expletive-laden rants at these people? Why harbor such hatred in your heart and words when you could just say, "Here's what bugged me, and how I fixed it. Now I don't need your product." That's all you need to say.
It just need to give a short pulse to start and open/close the door.
And to read out the door state I added a LDR circuit on the GPIO that is attached to the motor LED.
Has been working very well last three years using HA. no need for any of that expensive cloud connected hardware.
Wired and wireless layer 2 protocols have retransmission and your layer 7 app can receive duplicate commands. Be sure to add deduplication logic to the command e.g. using a nonce or transaction id. You have to be very careful that your layer 7 app doesn’t play the “open” command twice and close the door.
I’d happily buy your product to replace my MyQ. I hate the spam, and it’s just plain buggy. Plus the base station runs loads of unwanted services. I haven’t fully audited it, but I’m sure it’s a security nightmare.
Be sure to turn off/disable their old school RF stuff too.
Not surprising that they're pulling a John Deer and making simple things proprietary so they can enshitify you into their ecosystem.
You see when you install MyQ, by default it opts you in for in-garage delivery. And here's the beauty, you also need a PHD to figure out how to disable the setting in Amazon. (reference: https://support.chamberlaingroup.com/s/article/myQ-and-Amazo...)
> Push Notifications must not be required for the app to function, and should not be used to send sensitive personal or confidential information. Push Notifications should not be used for promotions or direct marketing purposes unless customers have explicitly opted in to receive them via consent language displayed in your app’s UI, and you provide a method in your app for a user to opt out from receiving such messages. Abuse of these services may result in revocation of your privileges.
I am frustrated that Apple isn't using their gatekeeping powers for good. I wonder if users can file a complaint.
[1] https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/#des...
Edit: yes, users can file complaints. If you are an Apple Developer, you can do so via https://developer.apple.com/help/app-review/safe-and-trusted...
You can also follow "Report A Problem" link at the bottom of the App Store's page for the app.
I.e. the rules above don't say "denying push notifications must not make the app less nice to use and consent for ad push notifications must be able to be toggled separately from other types of push notification consent".
They should, but that complaint probably needs to be directed at Apple.
Apple says that you must separate promotional marketing push notifications from regular push notifications, and allow users to opt out. this is in direct violation of that rule.
There are things that I hate more about the current level of the Torment Nexus than this, but surprisingly few of them.
> "Push Notifications should not be used for promotions or direct marketing purposes unless customers have explicitly opted in to receive [push notifications] via consent language displayed in your app’s UI, and you provide a method in your app for a user to opt out from receiving [push notifications]."
ie. if you use push notifications for marketing then you must ask the user if you can send notifications at all, and let them disable notifications.
It’s allowing them to bundle the baby with the bath water, so you can’t throw one out without the other. We see this kind of wording all the time and it’s peak enshittification.
"such messages" clearly refers to marketing messages only, because iOS already has a built-in way to block all push notifications for an app. You can just revoke the permission in system settings.
I don't think this is Apple intentionally writing a loophole into their own policy, they're just not enforcing it.
I.e. it doesn't matter what you can individually revoke, it matters what all you consent to when you want the app to register itself go start giving push notifications in the first place. This policy doesn't say that ask has to be separated anywhere, and a combined ask meets all it asks for.
E.g. "Would you like to receive push notifications, including our recommended product deals which... (yadda yadda)? y/n" (and the ability to undo that choice later) meet the quoted criteria to the letter without offering a way to have "good" push notifications without consenting to ad push notifications as well.
What would this look like? Web apps that give you more control over what specific notifications you get.
The best push notification is one that I don't have to click. "Your package from Apple has just been delivered". is infinitely better than "new activity on one of your deliveries, click to learn more."
We don't want companies optimizing for max(open rate) because that encourages the latter style.
There are tons of useful notifications I would like to get, but I end up having to choose the nuclear option of turning them off completely because I know that by allowing notifications, I expose myself to vomit-inducing growth hack spam.
%message%
template and continue to send their “time-sensitive” emoji slurry of marketing messages.Anyways, I completely agree.
But the apps themselves are doing such a dogshit job at this too. Telegram, or WhatsApp for example, has no way to completely disable messages from unknown senders. So the apps are quickly filled with spam.
To say nothing about how phone companies let spammers abuse their customers
They're a common carrier, you wouldn't want an automated fraud detection system to accidentally flag you and prevent you from ever obtaining another phone number in your country again.
This is the other side of the "why is Meta banning innocent people" coin. We could prevent Meta from doing this by law. What would the consequences be? I don't know, but I know that your car warranty has expired, are you interested in renewing it?
But if we assume that they are, all that would mean is that anyone is entitled to register a WhatsApp account. It wouldn't mean - could never mean - that anyone with a WhatsApp account is entitled to have their messages seen by anyone else they try to communicate with. Whether I take your call is between you and me, not between you and the phone company.
Sadly, the biggest Android OEM (Samsung) has decided to hide this feature in the settings app, meaning lots of users don't even know about it.
It also requires app developers to categorise their push notifications themselves, which they often refuse to do, despite Play Store guidelines requiring it.
Most people buy the garage door opener that's on sale. They aren't checking each brand's app reviews in Home Depot.
What would really help IMO is legislation requiring smart home appliances, especially ones that are semi-permanently installed, to be fully operable using open source tools or open standards.
It would also give every app location permissions in some cases (by detecting when you connect to open hotspots based on your IP).
Not to mention the battery life; having to reconnect 150 different TCP sessions every time you lose and regain coverage (which is quite often in some areas) would destroy battery life.
The correct design for push is what web browsers do. Make one user have one session to one server, with the user telling the app what server it should connect to and how to deliver their notifications. Connecting to hundreds of different servers for different users is a problem to be solved by the delivery service.
In principle, browsers could let you self host web push (I don't know if any of them actually do, but the standard does allow it).
We went from:
"gee, it sure would be nice if I didn't have to get out of my car and lug this heavy door open with my bare hands"
to:
"we can use the garage doors to advertise unrelated products to the owner, and/or participate in massive bot nets to ruin other people's lives!"
Now, I will admit it's convenient to be able to push a button rather than having to get out, open the door and get back in. But I don't know that it's worth the $150 for a garage door opener, which is why I'm still getting out and opening my garage door when I drive my car.
Someone should start a business ripping this crap out of garage door openers and replacing it with something sensible.
The boards themselves are not that complicated. They're just a couple relays to a motor controller, a couple safety switches, and a radio
Chamberlain has a MyQ Homelink module, did they discontinue that or something? I used it for a while, though I ended up ditching it because my Tesla never really got good enough range with it. Just as likely to be the Tesla module's fault as Chamberlain's, honestly.
(My openers themselves are 20+ year old Wayne Daltons, and I've revived one of them from a lightning strike and the other from a broken gear, but they've otherwise been trouble free.)
What could possibly go wrong 8-/
Siri, let me rob this house...
Hey, look I’m sorry. Wish I was at liberty to say how things got here.
On a lighter note, you may want to try rat-ratgo32 instead of ratgo32.
Showing 400 of 402. Read the rest on Hacker News
Comments are loaded live from Hacker News and are not stored by Mid or Real.
harrisonpage (author) 5d ago on HN
phrotoma 2d ago on HN