894 points | 4d ago | Discuss on Hacker News | Back to Radar
It was always so. It was so with Minitel and when JANET ran on X.25 instead of TCP/IP, and was so with US cryptography export controls, and was so with the Great Firewall.
The "free global internet" has always, always, been incompatible with national sovereignty.
None can be the servant of two masters for long, and that remains true when the servant is a corporation and the masters are nations. You can pick one, but you do have to actually pick.
Might cryptocurrency be affected, negatively or positively?
The US network will have an access agreement with the EU network. That will facilitate eg trade and communication to flow between those two tightly barricaded networks. Think of it like border walls and physical ports.
This is also how they'll attempt to control what AI is going to do to the Internet as we used to know it (destroy it extremely rapidly).
The Internet as the West thinks of it today will be de facto destroyed within ~5-7 years or so.
The next three or four years will be wild.
The solution, the sole way to slow it down, is to strictly isolate the major global networks. I should note that's the sole way to do it in reality (insert comments: yeah but if we just follow fantasyland ideals we'd do xyz and everything would be 197% secure). Right now all of our connectedness is an extreme weakness, it's by far our great weakness - almost nothing is ready. It will take way too long to upgrade the way we're doing things now (so, so, so slow), we don't have the time (time to get up to pace) or the incentive to be moving fast right-this-very-second, so the powers that be will pull drastic hammer moves instead out of fear for the economy.
Note that I'm not talking about some guy at home that knows how to run a Linux machine and look after his own network security. I'm not talking about Google's network. I'm talking about the other 99% of the economy that is wide open, built up on a garbage pile of poor practices in terms of security, focused on dealing with slow moving human threats, not millions of superhuman threats.
The capability of the attacks coming is beyond anything Cloudflare is ready for, for example. They're not even remotely prepared for what's about to happen. Every security firm is years behind the curve, pretty much none of them will outrun it. They'll be screaming in the halls of Congress for network isolation as a solution (to preserve their own businesses and reputations): they'll say if we just reduce the potential sources, if we reduce the easy access from outside, we can focus on securing our own USAnet (USAnet, EUnet, Runet, Chinanet, etc).
They'll isolate the major networks and more tightly regulate the AI within those networks. That will be the politician solution to the public fear and their own ignorance.
IMO, strict isolation is slightly more fantasyland than, say, having the AI make it all secure.
So, while you're:
> I'm not talking about Google's network.
I think even they would struggle.
For:
> I'm talking about the other 99% of the economy that is wide open, built up on a garbage pile of poor practices in terms of security, focused on dealing with slow moving human threats, not millions of superhuman threats.
I agree this group will handle it catastrophically badly, but I aver it will remain so if the attempt is "strictly isolate".
When I was doing my degree, it was reported that "12345" and "password" were among the top 10 passwords; if that kind of pattern is no longer the most common password, it is only because enough people banned it.
One story around the same time said you could get most people's passwords simply by asking for them. Another, that you could easily get onto a secure network by leaving a pen drive in the company's car park because someone would likely pick it up and plug it in - indeed, even supposedly air-gapped systems (e.g. the Iranian centrifuges) get hacked because people plug in things they're not meant to plug in.
Normal people are not paranoid enough for this. I am not paranoid enough for this despite being aware of it when I actually think about it. The NSA wasn't paranoid enough for this when Snowden did his thing, and human nature being what it is I'd be surprised if they became sufficiently paranoid even after that.
> They'll be screaming in the halls of Congress for network isolation as a solution (to preserve their own businesses and reputations): they'll say if we just reduce the potential sources, if we reduce the easy access from outside, we can focus on securing our own USAnet (USAnet, EUnet, Runet, Chinanet, etc).
Could be. As a non-American, this will be quite funny if this happens, given the economic impact inherent to the US from no longer being able to sell Big Tech to the rest of the world.
The decisions will be made by politicians. It will be made on the basis of power, control, fear, ignorance, public outrage, etc. It will be made in a moment of intense public uproar. They will not trust AI systems to secure the economy against other AI systems, that approach will take over a decade to deploy fully anyway, we don't have that kind of time. As the attacks rapidly increase, the politicians will reach for a hammer solution in desperation, and that one solution is intensive network isolation.
The politician will say: why are we allowing foreign actors access to our networks to harm us with AI? The answer is: there's no reason to allow it, it is not necessary. Note that China has done just fine with its network isolation, its economy has not languished for it, they will be viewed as proof that it can work well.
Big tech won't be prevented from selling to the rest of the world. They'll follow local laws/rules just as they have to right now. They'll help other nations build their own isolated networks (smaller nations will federate with other nations on this), and they'll offer services within those networks. Canada for example would be very likely to federate with the USAnet and EUnet.
They may not trust it, but the danger cannot realistically grow here faster than the solution, as it is the same tech.
> Big tech won't be prevented from selling to the rest of the world. They'll follow local laws/rules just as they have to right now.
The data centres are big and hard to move. Severing the trans-Atlantic internet connections will force big tech to build in Europe new data centres to support Europe, and take no advantage from time zones having Europe finish it's work day before California starts theirs.
Sometimes you encounter routing problems. Network A can't talk to network B because of some silly problem. When this happens, the team at Network A has to delve in and fix it.
You don't automatically have a single global network, there are people keeping it that way.
Ultimately, any government gets to decide which currency it demands taxes be paid in, and what is a lawful manner to settle an invoice or fine.
There's a bit of leakage around the sides and always has been, e.g. currency controls, exchange rate mechanisms broadly (and specifically the precursor to the Euro), and even before that there's a reason everyone left the gold standard.
But countries whose governments are cool with cryptocurrency can allow it, those that are not can ban its use. Will that cover all payments? Of course not, illegal goods and services aren't going to be put off by an illegal payment mechanism, but there's a whole model of "nations" being stationary bandits that also sees taxes as the same as organised crime protection money, and that kind of tangent leads to a whole book rather than a comment you can read in 20 seconds, TL;DR whose sovereignty is it anyway?
Thank you. Yes this was my initial thought process. Leaping predictions ahead, always a foolhardy endeavour, we are going to see less world domination but world divided. We're at the crazy paving stage.
This one or the medical definition will do... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crazy_paving
I doubt that; let’s not get carried away. There are more people on the internet now than we've ever had—about 6.3 billion and climbing [1].
If by "free" you mean being able to publish anything on the internet you want without restrictions, that ended a long time ago.
[1]: https://www.itu.int/itu-d/reports/statistics/2026/10/13/ff26...
When my private mail server in Australia sends a mail to yours in France, there's much less opportunity for interception than if we're both on Gmail. The routing probably goes through the USA where the NSA makes a note of the communication, and the certificates are from Let's Encrypt, so there are still a few remaining things to be solved but the situation is much better.
I think that is within means of a group of people with AI to create infrastructure for it.
That the integrity of the Internet is subordinate to or conditional upon some particular means of attempted redress, (effective or not) instant and with little oversight, is a political decision. It's not given.
As for the age of copyright, what does that matter? Copyright is man-made instrument with a particular purpose. It has been and continues to be useful, indirectly, for advancing some public interests. It has also generated some very powerful stakeholders who have proven quite able to bend government for the purpose of their own further entrenchment. But the relative value of copyright as an instrument to other public goods is neither fixed nor determined in any way by the age of this legal device whose purpose is to make sure books get written and so on.
Again, the lengths we should go to or means we ought to deploy to "protect copyright" at the expense of other institutions in society is not given. It's political and it's a choice. It's not a pre-determined ritual for properly recognizing some holy natural right.
Then y'all need to propose a non-real-time non-DNS alternative in detail, or fully bite the bullet and stand up in Parliament and say "abolish copyright" and fight that battle head on.
the relative value of copyright as an instrument to other public goods is neither fixed...
This is the level of discussion that needs to be had, but most people are just bleating "no blocking! no blocking!". Even if you're on the right side, that isn't a winning argument.
See e.g.:
Neil Netanel's Copyright's Paradox and his work on a noncommercial use levy.
Harvard Law Professor William Fisher's 2004 book, Promises to Keep: Technology, Law, and the Future of Entertainment and its "Alternative Compensation System".
Extended Collective Licensing, already available in several European countries.
Some of the provisions in the EU's Copyright in the Digital Single Market Directive.
Berkeley Law Professor Pamela Samuelson's work on collective licensing, e.g.: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC13416792/
Jacob Victor's Reconceptualizing Compulsory Copyright Licenses: https://review.law.stanford.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/3/2...
The only reliable defense against piracy that was ever found is "don't have anyone care about you enough to bother." Between the broader decentralization and democratization of content creation and the narrower case of the infinite content machine that is AI, the case for caring strongly about piracy is ever weakening.
So are horse-drawn carriages, so this doesn't tell us anything.
> you have to provide something.
We'll see, won't we? This isn't a one-sided battle, and not everyone agrees that the current incarnation of intellectual property laws are sensible, fair, or appropriate for the times.
The reason these laws exist in the first place is to strike a balance between creators, inventors, and the societies that support and pay for the creation of their work. They're broken in many ways right now, and the organizations fighting hardest to defend them are some of the most egregious exploiters of them.
Cases like the one in the OP are part of a kind of extended negotiation. Arguably, the defenders of existing IP law are fighting a rearguard action to defend an untenable position. That won't be enough in the longer term.
Slavery is thousands years older than copyright.
I propose a ban on recording sports matches. If you want to see it buy a ticket for the arena in which the game is held.
Why? With generative AI on the rise, I think piracy will outlive copyright. It would be far better to rethink how we entice and compensate the arts.
Everyday I open cloudflare's dashboard I see "security" firewalls blocking traffic from whole countries such as Iran.
Spain is renowned for being a shitshow in how their whole communication network is routinely subjected to de-facto denial of service attacks to prevent users from accessing live feeds of football matches.
I never saw any pushback from Cloudflare on how any of that was a Canary. Is a DNS provider insisting on ignoring a court order really the canary? This outrage seems awfully cherry-picked.
But beyond that, I don't care about Cloudflare. I don't care whether their corporate blog posts are opportunistic or not. I care about the internet. And I, at least, am disheartened by rules that block traffic from entire countries.
Western Europe had enjoyed a very long period of prosperity that is now in its death throes. cheap energy from Russia is over. China continues to devour manufacturing, and now AI begins to devour what's left. the austerity that lies ahead will piss off both the new Europeans and the old. what we see happening in France is going to happen in each of those countries, and they begin to take preemptive measures against the upcoming unlawful assemblies, which are only a good thing when they happen to unfriendly regimes.
They invented actual commoner democracy and endless pursuit of human rights as antithesis to their old systems, but rejected it while pretending to advocate for it without explaining that they expected it to be a mere absurdist counterbalance against old systems that could not possibly work in isolation, and it backfired spectacularly, but still haven't accepted what happened.
More specifically, Russias share in the energy market went like (2022 - 2025): Coal: 50% down to 0% Gas: 45% to 12% Oil: 27% to to 3%
If things continue to go as planned by 2027 Russias share in the EU energy market must have dropped down to below 0.5%.
https://commission.europa.eu/topics/energy/repowereu_en https://energy.ec.europa.eu/strategy/repowereu-phase-out-rus...
EU law also already requires CSAM scanning, right to be forgotten, bans on Russian state media, etc…
I agree, but everything they said was still correct
(Meanwhile, a few trillionaires are busy harvesting everything of value that people have put on it for their own benefit.)
We also have a steady stream of new taxes incoming
Easier said than done.
The hard reality is that politicians are fickle beasts. All they care about is where their next vote is coming from. As a result they always change their leanings depending on which way the wind is blowing.
"I would NEVER do that" says the politician.... a few months pass by .... "oh, well, the $insert_buzz_word_excuse_of_your_choice situation has changed, so that is why I voted for it in today's debate".
Anyway, how does it relate to the subject ? At the end of the day, LFI, is indeed one of the only party that voted against some measures that restrict internet freedom. Unfortunately, the running government really wants to control and to censor internet (the prime minister and the interior minister wanted to ban social medias during protests).
Simply related that I wouldn't vote for a basket case party over a single issue.
But hey, this is France. Socialism eh? Thank god ZRR exists.
This economic program was the cornerstone for 2027 program.
SMIC target Retirement Zucman tax
I really dislike politics here but as Thatcher put it, "the problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money".
Now, on the actual subject : we agree that with the Quad9 withdrawal, we should have listened to engineers more.
You don't agree that LFI and PS are the only ones who tried to listen to engineers, and economists, it's fine. But the truth is : they are the only one. Here are couple example on Tech and Video Games :
- Ugo Bernalicis law project about Stop Killing Games : https://www.assemblee-nationale.fr/dyn/17/dossiers/garantir_...
- Danielle Simonet about Layoff due to AI : https://www.assemblee-nationale.fr/dyn/17/questions/QANR5L17...
- René Pilato about AI Regulations and its usage for mass surveillance : https://www.assemblee-nationale.fr/dyn/17/textes/l17b3149_pr...
- LFI opposed the digital space regulation bill which enable mass surveillance and undermines privacy : https://lafranceinsoumise.fr/2024/04/18/projet-de-loi-visant...
I would take this argument a lot more seriously if it didn't come from fucking Cloudflare, the entity that puts all sorts of barriers to access this mythical "free and open" internet if you are not using the corporate-approved fingerprinted browser.
It's bad that France is doing this crap to suck the dick of copyright holding corporations, but the Internet has not been free nor open for a long time. This dream died under the boots of big tech already.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russo-Ukrainian_war
https://fiia.fi/en/publication/russias-hybrid-war-in-ukraine
https://www.ccdcoe.org/uploads/2018/10/Art-03-Russian-Inform...
27 February 2014 was when the threat profile across Europe changed.
How about https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Horsemen_of_the_Infocalyp...
Grids being taken down, social media disinformation being tightly peddled along with state media, constant attacks on internet infrastructure, etc.
That softened the path for the "intervention" that Russia began in 2014.
But the workflow above became the norm, and it was around then that hybrid cyberwarfare became the norm, and legislative priorities shifted.
Most HN boomers spent their formative years in North America and Western Europe in 1990s and 2000s, where such realities were thought to be over. Throw the hissy fit. You don't matter. YC owns all HN comments in perpetuity and logs user metadata.
How about https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intermittent_explosive_disorde...
Almost never hear these maximalist opinions when talking about it in real life,people seem way more open to the societal dangers
> Most HN boomers spent their formative years in North America and Western Europe in 1990s and 2000s
Probably not the biggest misconception in this comment, but FYI "boomer" means "born during the baby boom".Or is the opinion that words have meaning is itself outdated?
It's called lawfare.
And it's rich that Cloudflare writes about this when Prince made a hissy fit around 2-3 years ago with Portuguese border control when he was patted down under suspicion for bringing controlled substances.
Europeans didn't have their freedoms restricted during the cold war, and that was orders of magnitude more threatening to their survival than what's happening now with Russia.
And this is a war that has leaked heavily into much of the EU now as well.
The so called "freedoms" you describe only arose in a global anomaly in the 1990s-2000s when Cold War 1 ended, and that era definitively ended by 2014.
If you give your government that type of power over you in an emergency, what guarantee you have they'll not misuse it against you while they have it and even give it up after?
>And this is a war that has leaked heavily into much of the EU now as well.
Currently I'm more at risk by the misuse of power by my government, than of the Russian government. Russia is a gas station still stuck in the eastern part of Ukraine thanks to the Ukrainian military, only capable of sending some lawnmowers with explosive that we're working on taking down more efficiently, and their economy will be bankrupt soon. Claiming we need to give up our freedoms because of that as some Avengers level threat, is preposterous. We survived the cold war with less restrictions, and we were preparing to face the entire soviet army and nuclear holocaust.
>The so called "freedoms" you describe only arose in a global anomaly in the 1990s-2000s when Cold War 1 ended, and that era definitively ended by 2014.
Again, just because a war is happening somewhere on the planet, doesn't mean we should give up our freedoms. That's living under tyranny and then we're no better off than China, Russia, etc. putting us into Orwell's 1984 living under tyranny larping as the only way our governments can protect us from a forever boogeyman.
The war will eventually end and things will settle, as it happened after WW2 and after every war. The question is will our governments restore internet freedoms back to 2014 after that?
Let me explain. The biggest fear of any and all elected politicians is losing their lucrative cushy job at best, or angry mobs with pitchforks coming after them at worst. And the internet today replaced the main square where people congregate to discuss their issues with politics and arrange various forms of protests or retaliation against corruption or other failures of their leaders.
The internet also replaced the printed newspaper and the TV as the main medium from which gen-pop gets their info on scandals of corruption and policy failures of their leaders. After all, the internet and not the TV was the medium for some of the biggest political scandals got leaked, stuff like the Panama Papers on Wikileaks, etc
Now, if the government can't fully police or at least moderate what people read and do on the internet (as it did the main square, and TV broadcasts) then politicians are at risk of the angry mobs or losing their jobs.
So there you go, it's literally that simple. The internet just wasn't as influential to making or breaking political careers in the 90s-00s as it is today. That's why you see crackdowns happening now.
Now, the reason why EU and some EU countries are the ones you see spearheading this power grab of the free and open internet right now, under various guises (protecting the children, chat control, etc) is the massive amount of political dissatisfaction many EU citizens have with their upper government leaders today (see the protests in France, etc) which they blame for the 20+ years of bad policies which led to a sharp drop in prosperity, rise in CoL, and slow decline of their standards of living and welfare state, from school funding, to public healthcare, etc. that's been most evident since Covid (compound later with Russian war, energy crisis, Trump tariffs, loss of the auto industry, etc), to which most EU politicians don't have an answer how they can fix it and revert things back to "the good ol days" of the European social contract when everyone could easily get a decent paying job, afford rent in the big city, and expect to retire at 65 with a livable government pension, which realistically aren't ever coming back, but as a politician, there's no way to break this harsh truth to the people without them taking you to the guillotines for what they consider a bedrail of the social contract.
And this catastrophic failure of the social contract hurting Europeans now wasn't directly caused by Russia or Covid(remember rents and housing were rising faster than incomes way before those events, so something was gonna break eventually), but the famous European solidarity based welfare state was never gonna be sustainable long term from its inception in its original form, they were just kicking the can down the road passing the hot potato around from one administration to the next, offshoring jobs and printing money like crazy while enriching the shareholders, until Covid and Russia just collapsed the house of cards sooner than expect, and politicians of today are left with the hot potato to deal with, which they can't, so then internet crackdowns it is to prevent the peasants from organizing.
And Europe isn't alone here, but many governments will be facing similar challenges soon, including the US. So unless economic prosperity can somehow be restored to how it was before, you can expect harsher internet crackdowns from even more western governments, as political turmoil builds up. It's that simple.
Now I've called this happening years ago, that we are living in the last years of the open internet as Western governments saw what the CCP managed to achieve in China with the great firewall, the social credit score, WeChat dependence and ability to sanction anyone with a click, and how using these digital tools they can maintain control of the population without the need to ever use violence, and they want to implement exactly that, except they can't be too on the nose and upfront about it, so the frog gets boiled in steps at every crisis, and the great firewall they build for us gets covered in various nice coats of paint (protecting the children, protection from Russian disinformation, etc)
For better or worse, non-US governments lack the technical capacity to build this out themselves, so just hope to have a few hyper regulated US corps run it for them.
These American champions will be simultaneously defended from real competition and also arbitrarily fined or harassed by the state apparatus to keep them in line.
Of course people are going to wish they were able to curate the information landscape no person should be looking at the internet dialogue and thinking its healthy.
That's understandable. It makes me quite angry.
Why shouldn't we expect more of "the good old days"? Has technology been lost? What happened?
We seem to be like a very close and tight-knit family who wins 100 million in the lottery, and then a year later the parents are divorced, and the children are estranged and angry with each other, and half the family died from cocaine overdoses. What happened? Good things were happening, and then another good thing happened in the form of money, and then everything fell apart.
Society seems to be doing the same. We had a good thing, and then technology gave us more good things, and somehow adding good things to our good society caused it to fall apart. Who's to blame? I feel like somebody is to blame. I feel like there is a specific group of people who are to blame.
We seem to have built a society where if good things happen, society falls apart. If good things happen, society gets worse. Also, if bad things happen society gets worse. What happened?
I can't help but feel it's runaway capitalism or something.
I mean, we have better technology and individual people are more productive than ever, and society as a whole is more productive than ever. Why can't we still have "the good old days". Explain it to me.
I feel like the grift is on. Somebody is taking more than their fair share. Who could it be? What things might we look for to identify people who have taken more than their fair share?
I'm so sick of all the shit people do so they can make money I'm starting to just favor like a hard wealth cap--I have no idea what that would do to society, but it's not working for me and I'm pissed.
Almost all corruption from politicians or business owners, or anyone powerful in society, is done so they can make more money. If we just had a hard net-worth cap, those people who are already at the cap would have no incentive to do anything for more money.
i'm really getting tired of capitalism being the apparent cause of literally every societal ill, without any justification ever given.
What we have now is pure extraction ccapitalism. Just look at every company bought by PE.
>what solutions have you in mind for what you identify?
In essence the solutions aren't easy, at least not simple enough to write a comment about that.
A short introduction would be The secret history of Neoliberalism by George monbiot, which I can only recommend
Your response appreciated.
Imagine if we handled Hitler on time by ourselves, US industrial base would never get as crazy as it have had to get! EU wouldn't exist if it wasn't for D-Day! If you remember as late / early as Yugoslavia and the Slav war, EU did nothing there as well. It's doing nothing about Hormuz e.g.
Now the kids can larp as climate activists or communists while living off Grandma's pension that is financed by the rent from great-grandpas old colony in Congo / Algier or something like that.
Anything other that the US on the globe is basically just another flavour of communism (I'm exaggerating here for effect).
And the ultimate downfall of the EU(rope) was cemented the day the last US soldier left Afghanistan - August 30 or 31 (depends how you account for it) 2021, and it was Major General Chris Donahue.
The problem is that you can not make good decisions if you can not see the world for what it is.
You're only partially right. People absolutely know it can be worse, but they also know it can be better because they lived that just a few years ago(we're not even talking living like boomers did), and they don't want to accept a worsening of their situation, not when they see that it has definitely not worsened for the top 10%, but on the contrary, their wealth ballooned exponentially since 2019, while everyone below is being told they need to stop being out of touch and tighten their belts, while the fat pigs at the top have never had it better.
You can't call people stupid, brainwashed or out of touch, when the wealth graphs are out in the open and they don't lie.
AFAIU the core problem is most of the funding for our government, public services and welfare state comes from taxation of income and economic activity, which has shrunk a lot due to increases in automation(robots don't pay taxes), offshoring, uses of tax heavens and clever fiscal tricks, lack of investments into private industry development that create more new jobs that get displaced, and general globalisation, instead of from taxation of wealth which can be safely hoarded away while it balloons exponentially in your accounts without paying any taxes as long as you don't convert it to cash, which is what many people see as unfair and worthy of change.
Correct me if I'm wrong.
The good old days were always unsustainable. You were eating the seed corn and now you're wondering why this years harvest is so small.
Your proposals just amount to eating next years seed corn too. It will lead to the same results.
Regardless i'll try and list out what i think are his main complaints, and why each of them are unsustainable:
>everyone could easily get a well paying job,
Increasingly stringent labor laws make it difficult to get "a well paying job" when employers and employees are legally obligated to spend an enormous part of their compensation on whatever flavor of the day "employment rights" the government sees fit to legislate.
Mandatory paid vacations, safety regulations, anti-firing and anti-layoffs regulations, additional taxes (particularly "progressive taxes"), and a whole host of other regulations each have costs to both employers and employees.
If you're spending half your compensation budget on that, it's difficult to say the other half is "well paying".
Eating the seed corn grain by grain.
>afford rent in the city center,
Zoning regulations, anti-building regulations, anti-local housing regulations, anti-private property regulations, "safety regulations" for contructions, environmental regulations, etc... All of these are costs that ultimately result in less housing being built and therefore prices going higher.
That combined with the increased economic centralization, that in large part results from government policy means you have less housing being available in the most desired places.
Again, you're eating the seed corn, grain by grain.
>expect to retire at 65 with a livable government pension
The pensions were plain and simply never sustainable. The only reason you ever thought they were sustainable is because you didn't bother to look at how they are funded.
People see "Oh social security had a surplus this year" and think "why can't we get some of that?" when in reality that surplus never existed.
Any contributions to social security today create a claim on future cashflows from social security. And since most people get far more than they ever pay in, and the investments most systems make (if they make any!) are generally low risk low return, that means any contribution made over the past 100 years was effectively digging a deeper hole.
If governments were actually honest they would include those claims on future cashflows as the debts that they are, but that would require acknowledging that most european countries have debt to GDP ratios well into the 400%s. It would also require acknowledging that all those "surpluses" they like to bandy about were actually lies, and simply even larger deficits.
So they kick the can down the road and hope it will land under someone elses feet.
Eating the seed corn.
I think you will find i did not even mention society in either of my posts
Ctrl + F "collapse" = Zero entries found
Ctrl + F "fail" = Zero entries found
Wow look at that, neither collapse or fail were mentioned either huh
>Has technology been lost?
Yes, the chops needed in order to thrive without the internet have been in decline for a while. Much less without "big tech" and AI itself.
>What happened?
Also, the once-valued talent of financial people to enable prosperity before interest rates hit zero has been very largely eclipsed.
Free speech — no interference by government — has long been defended on “the main square, TV broadcast” and indeed the internet.
Commercial interests are my guess as to why unauthorized distribution of Hollywood films gets a domain on France’s DNS denylist
Specifics or references to what exactly? The history of angry mobs versus politicians and state control of media for their protection? The riots happening in October? CoL and housing rising faster than wages for the last decades? The fact that these issues compounded lead to social unrest? The fact that government crackdowns are proportional to amount of social unrest?
Open history books on what events lead to social unrest in the past and how the government politicians responded, see the news, economic performance and CoL graphs, use deduction and critical thinking and you'll arrive at the same conclusions I did. If you arrive at other conclusion, let's debate them, but don't just call everything you don't understand a conspiracy without having done any reach of your own and invested any effort to formulate a counter argument. You can take a horse to the pond, but you can't force it to drink.
governments can no longer keep kicking the debt and inflation can down the road, so now it's about damage mitigation and controlling descent.
I'm still shocked people on HN are having trouble putting 2 and 2 together and can't see the proportional correlation between internet crackdown and economic hardship.
you may believe politicians are smart or stupid, but their advisers working in national security are not, and it's pretty obvious that there is nothing governments can do to reverse the oncoming inflationary debt spiral, and eventually things will get bad enough that the population will rise up. we're seeing the beginnings of this in Europe.
My point with the long comment and all the tangents, is that the reason for the current internet crackdown from the social unrest, is a series of compounding issues accumulated over decades of economical and political mismanagement in the EU, that made our economy and welfare system be the world's envy for a while but also made it very fragile and vulnerable to even the smallest internal and external disruptions(and we had some big ones since Covid), and it's not as simple as a sibling Alephnerd here keeps claiming that "it's all because of Russia".
Russia didn't devalue our wages via infinite money printing during Covid. Russia didn't ship our manufacturing industry abroad. Russia didn't set up our nimby housing policies and open borders migration policies that directly increased rents. Russia didn't make the EU car makers ignore EVs and invest in stock buybacks instead of innovations. Russia didn't build our unsustainable pay-as-you go welfare state where the average pension in France is higher than the average salary. It was all our business leaders and policy makers we voted for who actively did this or passively enabled this to happen. Now people want to hold them accountable for the fallout, and the internet is where people go to discuss these issues and decide how we can peacefully retaliate, and obviously our politicians don't want us to get there too easily. So Russia makes the perfect scapegoat right now for why you need to trust that the government crackdowns on the internet are done "for your own protection".
And who decides which of the internet is "hostile foreign disinformation"? The ministry of truth?
I don't doubt there is disinformation out there, but I don't want the government to self appoint itself as the one and only true source of opinions we're allowed to have, just because some disinformation exists.
Since you say you don't need the government to confirm for you that the sky is blue then why do you need the government to filter the internet for you what is foreign disinformation, if identifying it is as easy as identifying the sky being blue?
I for one do not approve of my government treating me like a toddler that can't think for himself and think this entire idea is inherently undemocratic.
Your view of the noughties and mine seem to be rather different, possibly starting with I was actually there.
Please expand your argument and fill in some detail.
... or just bugger off ... bot.
Under this American media-hegemony, a European court and legislature is not really incentivized to prosecute their own citizens for the financial "crimes" against these massive multi-national American media companies. IIRC it actually took the US Government (lobbied by media companies) to pressure the European and Australian/NZ governments into actually criminalizing piracy.
The modern day is different. European countries now have a huge multinational industry that lobbies locally; football. Football (Soccer) is a massive cultural and economic influence now in Europe. As I understand the vast majority of these court mandated takedowns are from football rightsholders.
In the early days, the local lobby/legal organizations did pretty much immediately jump on peer-to-peer sharing and Usenet (I remember the Dutch Brein writing diatribes about copyright violation in the early 00s), but it was harder to enforce for various reasons. One of them being that local copyright laws were not really updated for the internet yet. Just to give an example, the Dutch law stated that you are able to make private copies of books, albums, etc. that you borrow (e.g. borrowing a book at the library and then copying it). This led to the legal interpretation that downloading copyrighted works from the internet was legal, only uploading wasn't. I took until 2014 until this interpretation was changed.
Aside from that, it was hard for copyright enforcement organizations to identify 'pirates'. Some ISPs fought having to give away private customer data nail and tooth.
The early-internet era was dominated by American media companies and culture.
This is really so factually wrong. This is the internet now. In the 90s and early 00s local media/internet companies were a lot more dominant in Europe. E.g. in The Netherlands 'De Digitale Stad' (a website where you could meet other people, build your own website) etc. were extremely popular in the 90s. Everybody was on the Dutch social network Hyves until the late 00s/early 10s. I know it's the same in other European countries (e.g. Germany had StudieVZ, etc.). The American internet hegemony really started at the mid to end 00s with Facebook, Youtube, etc.
Well that thing thing self-identified as "fakebook", so I'm not sure how much that really counts, given that it was a response to facebook and not something predating it.
It hasn't, but you kind of have to be on the ground to actually experience it. Alternative networks are around in Europe, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freifunk and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guifi.net are two real and active alternative networks you could join today.
There's still plenty of piracy in Europe, it's just a bit more underground. These companies are failing to prevent it, they're just lashing out in every way they can, causing immense collateral damage.
I grew up in the 90s and I remember slightly the idea that the UK was one of a handful of free countries, and that this was something to be proud of. However this sense that freedom and liberty are values to be celebrated I suspect (although may be I'm wrong), was an American import post-WWII, where America redefined the conflict, not as a battle between European powers, but of freedom vs totalitarianism. I think that narrative stuck around with that post-war generation, but my generation didn't care so much. When I speak to kids today and ask them what the values of the West are, they never talk about freedom.
Whenever I read these articles, they feel like they're written for someone from the past, or weirdos like myself who believe strongly in freedom as a virtue. But to assume the average reader cares about a free and open internet is genuinely absurd. The average person feels the internet is far too open and permissive. I don't think this is an argument we can win without a fundamental shift in our cultural values first.
Quad9 is a small Swiss profit , the French case is for enforcing football licensing interests that have been bought by the Qatari royal family in the French league.
DNS is like the post office or the address book and is a public utility. The ask is for post not deliver mail or list in address books the addresses of suspected criminals.
Considering how UK regulates water, power or rail transit , I am not sure that people there thinking this is a successful regulatory action is a good thing.
The legal warfare is driven by the beIN Sports chairman, Nasser Al-Khelaifi. He is also president of Paris Saint-Germain and chairman of Qatar Sports Investment.
He is, obviously, not French.
His self-claimed annual income was about $15–25 million, and his personal wealth was about $70–100 million.
Qatar, obviously, is not a friend of open Internet.
Caroline Guenneteau is General Counsel of beIN Media Group. She is self-stated leading voice in sports law and anti-piracy in sports broadcasting.
She was a founder and remains an active board member of APPS, the industry association created in 2018 that brings together broadcasters, leagues and sports bodies to censor Internet. Through APPS and beIN she has advocated dynamic court orders that allow rapid blocking of pirate sites and their mirrors, DNS blocking by internet service providers, and greater responsibility from platforms and search engines. She has noted the difficulty of securing voluntary cooperation from French ISPs and has supported legislative changes, including the 2021 French law that introduced dynamic blocking mechanisms.
https://www.beinmediagroup.com/the-group/caroline-guenneteau...
So you want to help? Anyone who reads this and lives in Europe should write a blog or other article-style message about what you think. In French? Not necessary, but even better. Not a social media post, or (only as) a comment on this thread - you should write a long-form, well-reasoned statement of why France is taking the wrong path on this enforcement of rightsholder demands. Make sure your post is scrape-able by search engines and AI. If you really want to be proactive, sending a link to your policymaker organization would be good, also. Post/link it here, maybe.
It is a serious problem with Gemini, you really have to research sources deeply to understand its biases.
We all need to start exploiting this. God knows the bad guys are.
Companies like sky own both internet and broadcast handshakes, might be easier for them to pinpoint users and block on a per user basis
networks noob here btw
If you just rip a bluray and put it on the torrent network, how exactly do you fingerprint that?
https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2025/03/libge...
Why should someone's value of something I bought with my own money (an mp3 file) be transitively imposed on someone I want to sell _my_ property to?
I bought this piece of music, and now it's MINE, and I sell it to anyone I want for as much money as they are ready to pay.
why should your perceived concept of ownership be forced upon everyone else ?
i don't believe it's possible to "own" soundwaves.
Many people seem to assert that property, including "intellectual property", is sacred in this sense. I don't agree. I think property is just a human norm that should serve us and not the other way around. But it's hard to argue with a sacred belief.
They filter out sites that are deemed to be nasty - you'll have to check their docs on what nasty means and whether it gibes with your idea of nasty.
The issue here is that they are being required to filter beyond their self-imposed mandate, by the EU, so they decided to bug out. Again, you will have to look up what the extra requirements are and decide for yourself.
That means that you lose a service that might be useful to you.
I don’t think IP law is worth contorting our whole society to make it work. But, stopping it at the source using the courts seems very difficult.
OTOH if fingerprinting is good enough, maybe just cancel their accounts (for streaming services at least). No need to involve the courts.
It's all about truth and messaging.
DNS tells you where something is, no more and no less. When queried, it points to the map and says: "It's there, off you trot". DNS does not care what is there, it is just a guide.
DNS works over port 53/udp+tcp and could be fiddled with in transit. There is a variety of DNS called DNSSEC which, with care, can be trusted to be accurate (for your given value of accurate).
Messaging: As I said, port 53/udp+tcp could be fiddled with if DNSSEC is not in play. There is also DNS over HTTPS or DoH. Now the messaging channel is encrypted. At this point you have the same confidence in security as you do when looking at https web sites.
Now, you can obviously use DoH DNS from anywhere in the world and it will look like ordinary web traffic. Most browsers are already doing this.
Messing with DNS now in Europe is basically fiddling whilst Rome burns - bloody stupid and couterproductive. Hamstringing a service such as Quad9 is at best ridiculous.
It's not end-to-end encrypted, nor authenticated for that matter. There's no substitute for DNSSEC, though like a VPN, DoH makes it easier to evade local or regional interventions. (And because I know DNSSEC triggers some peope, I'll point out myself that WebPKI is a proper end-to-end solution that prevents using DNS to MiTM... mostly. Without DNSSEC acme verification techniques are less than ideal.)
Does anyone know how the automatic (non-system) built-in DoH in browsers selects a resolver? I assume they don't globally utilize the same DNS resolvers, as that would break GeoDNS and cause performance issues; at least if those resolvers aren't doing the backend resolution in a way that preserves locality.
Keep in mind the audience making the decisions here is perfectly happy to require that geographical maps be censored to obscure sensitive locations. From their perspective, this is much the same thing.
Can you elaborate on where you would like to attack the problem? Because Cloudflare (as discussed elsewhere in this thread) is a notorious enabler of major piracy sites (and even profits from providing services to them). Domain registrars favored by pirates usually don't want to get involved, and neither do Internet transit providers.
Essentially, the companies who directly or indirectly facilitate and profit from piracy wants to point the finger at the host -- who is inevitably an internationally located bulletproof provider, who refuses to take any action since that's their entire business model. Everyone else in the chain want to play dumb, as if they're not involved.
It seems to me that every company involved and profiting off piracy should have a duty to take steps to minimize the further harm they cause to content creators when they are properly made aware of illegal content.
Edit - an even simpler and more direct analog: if Cloudflare was knowingly providing services to a site that let you order illegal guns, the ATF would absolutely be able to take action against Cloudflare and it's executives.
Poor analogy - DNS providers aren't shipping pirated material to the end-user. They just provide the address. They don't ship anything.
Stop trying to solve piracy by chasing every link in the chain in ever more frustrating ways demanding they solve your issue.
Accept a few core things
1. 0% piracy is impossible.
2. You can significantly reduce piracy by making your content easy to access for everyone and charging a fair price (see also steam).
3. You cannot demand both no piracy and carve out weird regional or international rules for your content.
Piracy was down globally after streaming became mainstream and cheap, it's only coming back now because of greed and the splintering of content into different platforms.
This is what happens when the opposite starts to again become true
The reality is the early streaming economics were not sustainable. Netflix was operating at a significant loss due to massive investments in content production. Prices inevitably had to go up. Similarly, fracturing was inevitable as other studios faced the same profitability issues.
Pirates live in this world where they've convinced themselves they somehow know better than the content producers, and simple business realities are reduced to 'greed'. And yet those same pirates would cry foul if their own pay was withheld from them.
In other words: Netflix was practicing predatory pricing [0] and would never have become a quarter-trillion company without it?
If their revenue covered licensing plus hosting, the price wasn't causing any significant problems.
Not having an answer to this question does not make the assertion "This is the wrong place to attack the problem" wrong in any way.[1]
So, worst-case scenario, no one has an answer to your question, but that doesn't invalidate the assertion anyway, so why ask the question?
I also find it hilarious that trillion dollar companies can strip-mine all of human creation and sell it back to humanity for a profit while devaluing labour, but the minute someone is copying movies, with almost no negative effect on anyone else, suddenly laws are required.
------------------
[1] After all, we can also attack the problem by requiring everyone get government permission to use their computers, or handover all credentials on their computer to their government, but you wouldn't produce the asinine response "If not on the user's computer, then where do you recommend we attack the problem?" Just because someone points out that an idea is bad does not mean that they also need to provide a better solution. Just saying "This is a bad idea" is sufficient.
They are trying to coerce these companies into proactively removing anything that could even be inferred to be violating.
Which will hurt users more and save the companies a lot of work.
So yeah it seems to be more of a feature than a bug to me.
In permissive compliance mode you ask forgiveness not permission, or better yet, you don't even let them know. When the auditors come by you make sure they see you meet all their checkboxes, even if you actually don't. Example: a video streaming company that always uses the same DRM key, decrypts video as it arrives, passes unencrypted video blocks around willy-nilly over a VPN and re-encrypts it just before it's sent to a customer. They have a successful product because they have a lot of flexibility and low constraints. They pass audits because auditors find what they're looking for (all outgoing streams encrypted).
Obstructive compliance is failing on the side of denying access. This is what people do when they think the point of compliance is to strictly meet the criteria all the time. If they're not sure about anything it gets denied. Example: a video streaming company that strictly never decrypts the source's DRM and passes encrypted video blocks around, and only stores keys wrapped in some security layers, will have quite a lot of difficulty delivering features like timeshift.
The most successful businesses do permissive compliance, but part of being permissive is looking like you're being obstructive, so that gets copied.
For me, compliance run by a team of engineers is when things became intolerably obstructive. At another place, when compliance was managed by a team of techy paralegals placed as a barrier to keep the auditors away from engineering, it felt much more productive.
I am sure the compliance team were both passing themselves off as real engineering to the auditors, as well as showing them all the examples they could muster about how they had obstructed all manner of awfulness at the command of the all mighty auditors. Meanwhile we just shipped stuff.
Let's take Cloudfare's phonebook analogy: say the yellow pages accept explicit ads for heroin dealers, stolen good resellers or(in a country where that's prohibited) prostitution - we can all agree that the problem is best resolved by arresting the heroin dealers. But what if these guys switch houses every day or are in a place police can't readily go? Off compose some already have the dealer's WhatsApp, but the main way new customers find them is through the yellow pages - would we not all expect the government to take action against the yellow pages until they stop? And if the yellow pages say 'but there are ten other company-name-to-address resolvers and they are also selling scam ads ripping off old people, so you are harming the citizens by penalising us', would anyone buy that argument?
I'm not saying you're wrong. But there is a clear policy problem and I can see how those with decision making power are choosing this route. It's also not your analogy, but I think the cloudfare article is pure pandering to those already convinced and handwaves the underlying problem that DNS resolvers pay a - tiny and easily replaceable, but real - role to facilitate law breaking.
It seems then the rather best argument is about the risk of censorship due to the global nature of DNS. I want to be able to criticise the Thai and Saudi kings. I want to talk about Tiananmen and prostitution and affirm my believe that god doesn't exist and homosexuals have a right to live.
So how do we bring these together? You and the other DNS can't legitimately claim innocence when you are part of a chain that facilitates crime (whether you agree that the action should be a crime is irrelevant). It's unambiguously clear that DNS play a role, no matter how good you and the others are otherwise.
So currently the DNS are facilitating crime, and the reply is 'its unavoidable', and the reaction to legal action is to withdraw. I see both sides, and there is definitely no black and white answer - so isn't three a need for technical solutions? Not saying quad9 should offer this, but if the aim of 1111, 8888 and 9999 is an open internet, it seems there is a need to still offer governments some kind of solution to the problem?
Claiming that DNS providers contribute towards cybercrime is like saying knife manufacturers contribute towards stabbings. Let's not blame the tools when when the fault lies entirely in the hands of those abusing said tools.
They are not tools for building canals (tried that, didn't work).
They are not tools for lifting starships to space (back of the enveloped that one, didn't work).
No good for food preparation (although radiation is used) unlike a knife.
Nuclear weapons are pretty shitty tools - their only function is to threaten usage or be used to kill. At a city scale (mini nukes aside).
Do you support the village idiot buying a city killer weapon?
The main thrust above is that nuclear weapons aren't in the same tool category as either DNS (literal digital phone books) or knives (useful for many things unrelated to killing or injuring other humans).
The village idiot? We already have requirements for buying and handling explosives (which results in the interesting edge case of Tannerite. High explosive, legal to buy and use, but not legal to transport or store. You mix A and B to make it on site, if you don't detonate it you need to destroy it) and the bigger the boom the more restrictions there are. I see no reason a civilian should have looser security rules on a nuke than the military does--and the military operates on a two man rule basis. Thus your village idiot can't actually possess a bomb. But I see no reason Acme Asteroid Movers shouldn't be allowed to buy a detonation--they pay $x, the military delivers the bomb to the asteroid and sets it off. They get ownership in the right to direct it's use, not ownership as in physical possession.
I'll only chase a distracting rabbit so far down a hole.
> Thus your village idiot can't actually possess a bomb.
How do we characterise https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timothy_McVeigh who did in fact possess and use a bomb to destroy a federal building and take many lives?
"If you would ban nuclear weapons, you should also ban <something else>" is fully generic. Anything can be used for crime. Criminals could use picture frames for forgeries, so we should ban picture frames. Criminals could use buses to get to the scene of the crime, so we should ban buses. Criminals could use food to distract the victim, so we should ban food.
The reason nuclear weapons are prohibited and strawberries are not is that nuclear weapons are weapons of mass destruction. Whereas phone books, not so much.
> The question isn't if it facilitates crime at all. It's if it does so in a way that's impactful enough that the cost of removing/limiting it is worth the gain to society.
There are scores of technologies now in everyday use whose early adopters were ne'er-do-wells. More to the point, when times are good the technologies that allow the public to resist an oppressive government will find among their primary users the least savory people imaginable, but if you correspondingly stamp them out then you're in for a world of pain the next time the wheel turns.
A thing should be prohibited only if not prohibiting it would be unambiguously and irreversibly catastrophic. You shouldn't be looking at grey areas, it should be only the cases that are so obvious that you can't credibly be prohibiting something in error.
What was done here was a false equivalence. Defending DNS neutrality because DNS is a tool being equated with defending free access to the most horrific weapons systems ever devised by calling it "just a tool". Absurd, yes. Reduction ad absurdum? No.
Much like "begging the question" is not something which invites further inquiry, but assuming your conclusion is true, and "strawman" is not weakening the opposing argument but inventing a weak argument to refute instead of addressing the real one, "reduction ad absurdum" is not making preposterous conclusions from an argument and pretending it invalidates the argument, it is following some theorem to an absurd conclusion to show that it is in fact flawed for leading to contradiction.
I'd say a reduction ad absurdum was attempted but merely a clumsy strawman fallacy was achieved.
> contribute towards cybercrime
Do you see how you manipulate here? If you stick to the original words, are you going to say that knife manufacturers do not facilitate stabbing? Because I'd say they do. Just like gun manufacturers do.
The question isn't if it facilitates crime at all. It's if it does so in a way that's impactful enough that the cost of removing/limiting it is worth the gain to society.
Fully agree with you on the final question. The answer by cloudfare is 'no', the French government says 'find a way'.
We need a return to personal responsibility, no a gun manufacture or a knife manufacture didn't facilitate a crime - the criminal did - and in both cases if guns nor knives never existed they would have found some other item (sharpened stick) to do the same thing.
Regulation on knives and guns to limit their harm is fine - not because the OBJECT is dangerous but because we can't trust the humans to not do shitty things with it - but lets stop blaming them for the actions of people.
if they say “we can’t afford bouncers” or whatever, we don’t give them sympathy, we say “then your business plan is wildly flawed. bars and clubs always attract people who try to peddle drugs. this is well known. clubs are expected to have security and you get no sympathy as you failed to consider basic shit in your business plan. we’ll give the liquor license to someone who is smart enough to include a budget for security in their business plan.”
again, i do likely lean towards quad9s position in this instance, but on a larger scale, the lack of accountability we give to some companies just because they’re online is a bit absurd. it’s not at all clear to me why, until recently, we’ve been refusing to hold some to even basic standards we would hold other businesses. “aww you didn’t consider the most obvious and basic likely things to happen or how to mitigate them in your business plan? awww bummer, carry on.”
This is the thing where people claim slippery slope is a fallacy when they want to start requiring liquor licenses and then start teflon-coating the slope immediately thereafter.
> it’s not at all clear to me why, until recently, we’ve been refusing to hold some to even basic standards we would hold other businesses.
The answer is that we don't do any such thing with the vast majority of other businesses. FedEx isn't expected to open your packages and check for contraband. The bus driver doesn't interrogate you about where you just came from or what you're planning to do after you get off the bus. The hardware store isn't expected to care why you're buying a shovel.
Because they're not the police nor should they be.
In most western countries and the law follows the concepts "Presumption of innocence" and "Direct Perpetration" that reasoning seems to be getting lost in a lot of modern discussions about law enforcement (age verification is one). I would suggest you read up on the foundation of rule of law.
Following your example, just because you chose to call Quad9 (a public address resolver) to ask for the address of that bar does not mean they should censor that information because you may(or may not) be going there to buy/sell drugs. That is ridiculous requirement, besides you could've asked your friend for the address anyway. The police should arrest the dealer in this case.
You’re trying to create a circular argument here when the exact topic of discussion is what those local laws and regulations should be
That's not their intent clearly, and their role is very minor. But the question is how much responsibility they have to prevent it. That's the entire substance of the debate. France says they are responsible, quad9 says they can't do anything about it. Neither party questions that there is a role.
To get a bit philosophical, Marshal McLuhan would (somewhat) disagree with this: the tools we make and use certainly shape our actions (and the perception of the environment we live in).
If you follow that analogy, registrars are the Yellow Pages and they should be doing the due diligence, not the postman.
After finding them on the yellow pages, the customers call them with cellphones, so cellphone makers are also responsible?
I don't think anyone's saying that technical solutions are by definition unnecessary. Whether or not it is, is just not relevant to the matter at hand.
Roads facilitate crime. Opposing the removal/blocking of roads is not approving of crime, and it's not on the opposer to propose a better solution to crime. The cost of blocking roads easily outweighs the benefits of reduced crime, and that is all that is needed to decide not to do it.
Yellow pages example was used for the "comprehensive listing of all phone numbers" property, not for the ads.
Perhaps think of it as actual street addresses and house/building numbers assigned by local city council instead?
If a criminal activity happens at "address X" — which is a way to locate a particular property in a town, just like a domain name is translated with DNS to an actual internet IP — do you hold the maps provider (like Google or Apple Maps, or OpenStreetMap) accountable for that address still pointing to the house at that address? Should navigation stop working to this address? Should authorities be alerted when someone puts that address in into their navigation software?
City councils are "distributed" in the same way domain names and TLD registrars are, so map providers aggregate the data from all of them. Some councils are "rotten" and probably take bribes and do who-knows-what when assigning addresses and do not take care of the crime in their jurisdictions. Just like some TLDs and domain owners.
Are "navigation providers" really the place to tackle this issue?
White pages are like an IP address. Yellow pages are more like a purchased domain name.
So let’s say in the Netherlands where prostitution is legal, there are a bunch of yellow pages ads for prostitutes. Should France have to allow those yellow page ads in France where prostitution is illegal?
If we focus on the functional usage and not the technical implementation, I think the analogy could be more that domain names are like phone numbers and IP addresses are like DTMF tones, but even that is imperfect.
10x worse
I challenge this assertion. The white pages are exactly what DNS is - you rent a phone number and the association of your name to that phone number (in the phone book).
But I do acknowledge what you’re saying and where you’re coming from. Maybe I’d chalk this up to “most analogies anre imperfect.”
If so, that's unrelated to the role of DNS servers/resolvers like Quad9, which is to be deferent to nameservers and simply respond to queries quickly and reliably with whatever the upstream source of truth describes. Law enforcement would be better off going straight to the source of truth itself.
Street addresses is the human readable form that translate into a position. They are as close to domain names as you can get in an real world analogy.
Yellow pages are the equivalent of paying Google Ads to advertise your product.
If prostitutes in the Netherland are paying French news papers in France to advertise prostitution, then the correct response is to stop the French news papers. Destroying maps of the Netherland, or closing the border to the Netherland would both be massive overreaction and would harm the diplomatic relationship between the countries. The Internet analogies of those are DNS blocks, or the use of a national firewall.
I guess it also depend a bit on how one want to look at it. A physical location will have their lat/lon coordinate change very slowly as continents slowly moves. Nothing in this world is truly ever static.
Should it be illegal to import a phone book from the Netherlands into France just because it happens to have advertisements for prostitution?
Why shouldn't people in France be allowed to see ads for prostitutes in the Netherlands? Are French people subject to French law wrt prostitution if they go to the Netherlands to patronize prostitutes? If they're not, what's the basis for keeping them from seeing ads?
A yellow page ad is full of extra information and enticement.
A list of naked IP addresses isn't like the white pages, it's as useless as having the list of every phone number in your pocket: for i in range(1e11): print(i)
I think in your example the question is less the address, which is a real physical property, and more whether searching google maps for 'dan's drugs' should show an address. Google will remove such listings if they are reported.
Of course, all analogies break down at some level, especially when comparing the physical world with digital: while addresses (and even plot IDs with re-plotting and zoning changes, if you want to equate them to IP addresses for instance) can change, it is a relatively slow moving and rarer occurrence than re-pointing a domain at a new IP address. Where I am at, new developments in suburbs usually start with numbered streets and then evolve into deserving citizen's names over several years (sometimes decades).
Analogies only work if we focus on the part that makes them analogous — if we don't, they usually break down quickly :)
Now, a correct rebuttal would be to point to reddit where there are subreddits for every geographic location to find local drug dealers.
Cloudflare used it to explain what DNS is, not to explain their argument. I believe that the analogy works well to explain what a DNS is. You're the one stretching it further.
You say that like DNS advertises piracy. Please explain how the domain name system is in any way comparable to a user-searchable database for services, and not simply a postal code database linking alphanumeric codes to physical locations?
If it says Frank Smith (heroin dealer) 555-1234 the phone book is now advertising heroin and the government can make them remove that. If there's a whole section for heroin dealers the phone book themselves are now criminals for adding that section in.
Let’s say a heroin dealer puts their name in the yellow pages in the plumbers section. Obviously that’s not the phone book’s fault. But then the phone book company is informed that Joe’s Plumbing is actually a heroin dealer that has been evading police. Now the phone book company is aware and inaction is an action.
They shouldn't have lost the case.
If they can't, it's either because of incompetence, underbudgeting, or more likely because the legal framework is not as clearly in their favor as corporate lobbying try to paint.
Quad9 definitely became aware when content rights holders sent them whatever precursor to a lawsuit they sent them.
If they got paid to list a plumbing business they may continue listing a plumbing business. Whether it is a plumbing business or not is someone elses job.
> Quad9 definitely became aware when content rights holders sent them whatever precursor to a lawsuit they sent them.
It's not Quad9's job to litigate that. Quad9 isn't hosting anything that may or may not be illegal.
No, it’s not Quad9’s job to litigate that, in fact here they were litigated against by another private company and they lost their case.
I don't watch any sports, so I'm only interested in the capacity of slippery slope arguments, but everything from the fiber owner, my ISP, my GPU, my monitor all contribute to me watching something on the internet, should they all be responsible for what they process/transfer once informed?
Just because you can force DNS providers to unlist something (for anyone not able to reroute) doesn't make it a good measure for culpability, but IANAL.
No?
I should also correct my last comment. The DNS provider is the LEAST culpable since it doesn't actually carry any of the content, compared to fiber, ISP, GPU, monitor which all do.
We can preach technical justifications all day long, but Quad9 lost in civil court against another company that brought their grievance to a court.
They were determined to be at fault in civil court. They're either in the wrong or they need better lawyers.
From the perspective of the plaintiff, Quad9 is actively harming them, and the court agreed.
The fiber company might be more culpable or whatever, but they weren't the defendants brought to court by the plaintiffs.
> They were determined to be at fault in civil court.
It's generally called "no-fault injunctive relief" because they are, literally, not at fault.
If your jurisdiction can't follow the road sign and shut down the illegal activity where it occurs, we shouldn't move to remove the road signs, we should either rewrite laws such that the illegal activity is easier to crack down on, or as a society accept that money shouldn't equal right in a court of (civil) law.
Nothing in that comment was hypothetical.
That doesn’t matter, Quad9 is the entity that the plaintiff decided to take to court.
We have plenty of cases of copyright challenges with no infringement, including multiple cases where the challenge is from someone who actually stole it from the person being challenged. The whole copyright challenge system has become a guilty until proven innocent, with punishment to be doled out before there is any attempt to verify.
And we have seen multiple cases of where taking out something clearly infringing also took out a bunch of nearby stuff.
You want me to believe the challenges, make a system in which the falsely accused have meaningful recourse and in which the challenger is automatically guilty of any collateral damage from the request. (And, yes, I recognize this would be an intolerable provision. They couldn't go around the web shooting their shotguns any more than I could walk down the street using a shotgun on pigeons.)
Quad9's position seems to be that even when the request they are responding to is openly asking for something illegal (i.e. "please tell me the IP address for hire-a-hitman.cn") and someone has gone and told them that "hire-a-hitman.cn" is in fact a site for hiring hitman and a court has ruled that they must stop directing people to it they should still be allowed to direct people within the courts jurisdiction to it so long as those people take very simple steps to avoid announcing they are within the courts jurisdiction.
Of course the actual crime at hand is copyright infringement - but none of their arguments rest on that.
What if my legal name happens to be Wesell Heroin?
Required to deny? No, but they shouldn't be surprised when the police come knocking at their door with a search warrant stating that they have probable cause that they are conspiring to sell heroin based on the listing that directs people to a place to (apparently) buy heroin. That the investigation will eventually fail to provide the requisite proof to convict them is... uh... some comfort? And if it turns out that "Wesellheroin Plumbing Ltd" is in fact selling heroin they're going to have to have some damn good argument for how they weren't wilfully ignorant to that fact to not be criminal co-conspirators.
(All this assumes a phonebook that has actual knowledge of the listing names. If an automated system put the "Wesellheroin Plumbing Ltd" listing into the phonebook and no one involved in running the phonebook was aware of it they lack the requisite criminal intent... until they become aware of it and continue shipping phonebooks)
"Free speech" is a fairly generic term where the boundaries vary between countries, but generally it means that but for carve-outs you can say and not say what you want. Carve outs generally include things like "commercial speech intended to mislead".
I'd also expect that in many places with reasonably robust free speech laws might require to not refuse listings because the lister is in some list of protected classes (e.g. gender, ethnicity, ...). But nowhere is "apparently actively committing crimes" a protected class.
The american law around this concerns whether there is a substantial legitimate government interest in overcoming the free speech rights. In your example I'd think the courts would find one for lying about the other companies number (but not for merely declining to give it). If the phonebook-gravedigging-company has a monopoly on phonebooks maybe a competition (in a lawful market) based one for refusing the other companies listing. But neither of those interests are applicable in the case of responding to DNS queries for criminal activities.
I don't have an answer, but the cloudfare article simply says 'we shouldn't do anything, keep resolving' which feels off.
Well, they should immediately impose 10 000 000x stricter/higher penalties on all AI firms that committed far more serious copyright crimes, for starters.
Then calculate out what those penalties come to, on a daily basis, from when these companies actually committed those copyright violations (that was in January 2021 for Anthropic and 2016 for Meta, in other words they already owe 3600 times the daily penalty), and immediately impose those damages on the AI companies, to be paid out the authors of those books illegally downloaded and used for profit.
Seriously, that's step ONE. Because if this step isn't taken, can the court then just stop pretending copyright exists? Courts in France are specifically barred from applying the law selectively.
And I understand that while the cloudflare article makes it more about copyright, this is also about other crime.
And NO, you cannot do what the US congress claims they did: you cannot change the law. That doesn't change that these actions were crimes when the companies committed them, because even congress can't change the past.
So the only discussion becomes which illegal things are they filtering, and who gets to decide what things are on their filtering list.
In the example speak: the French government said you need to make sure no French person gets anything else then the French phone book (with the redacted numbers). Quad9 said that's impossible, we make only one phone book. Besides French people can ask their friends from Germany to send that phone book over and Quad9 would be liable. The only way is to redact the numbers in all versions (what they are doing with malware) or don't sell the phone book in France at all. They don't want to redact all versions as that would mean people in Germany or the USA would have to submit to French law. Their only option is to stop serving French people all together.
> Quad9 has already tried this, in Germany. In the Sony Music v. Quad9 case, Quad9 used geoIP blocking for German users while the case continued. Sony's lawyers used a VPN to reach the content "from Germany" anyway, the court agreed this was non-compliance, and Quad9 was fined for contempt.
> As Quad9 told TorrentFreak: "There is no legally useful way for us to define a French user."
That explains that the difficulty of GeoIP likely not being sufficient for the court as was tried in Germany. This is not a technical issue but an issue of what the court would find sufficient, and the need to identify a user as French. By saying they don't serve French altogether I think they are dodging the non-compliance on the current case.So are gun manufacturers. But actually, so are hammer manufacturers. Why aren't we looking for a solution preventing those being used for crime? Because it's actually hard.
> isn't three a need for technical solutions?
A need, surely. Is there a pragmatic technical solutions? Well if there was, then it would be a lot smarter to enforce that than whatever France is doing, right?
My point being that the best thing to do when we don't have a good solution (France doesn't) is NOT to do something that is not considered a good solution (by definition, since we just said we don't have a good solution) and claim it's better than nothing. Many times, bad solutions are worse than nothing.
Note: the "it's better than nothing" and "at least we are doing something" is often used against immigration. A bad solution to real problems. Why do politicians go for that? Because apparently people still don't understand that "something random" is not necessarily "better than nothing". They would if they were the targets of those policies once in a while, and that's exactly why it works with immigration: because those who are targeted and may actually understand that it's not always "better than nothing" don't have the right to vote.
And most countries don't heavily limit how hammers can be sold. But they could: we could enforce that when someone buys a hammer, we ask an AI to do a background check and say if they should be allowed to own a hammer, right? But would it be better than nothing? I assume you will agree that it's not so sure.
Ok, not for a hammer. What about a car? We could enforce that everyone is tracked when driving, and then feed that to an AI that would guess how likely we are to eventually cause an accident. Then we could prevent those "potentially dangerous drivers" from having a car at all. Would that be better than nothing? Not so clear.
The truth is that the world is complicated. And often there aren't perfect solutions to real problems.
Security is typical of a complicated problem that fundamentally requires tradeoffs. The thing is, security is also control/power. And it adds up: there are many, many individual cases where we would say "well it may (or may not) improve security, but the cost is a little bit of freedom, so we may as well pay it, it's better than nothing and it doesn't hurt". Except that if you systematically give up freedom for an unclear security benefit, what you do is that you move the balance towards more control/power (and therefore less freedom).
The argument that they are facilitating crime is wrong from the start.
That's not how innocence works. You're arguing that because they could do something, they should do something. I'm not a fan of spreading enforcement all over the place, and I wouldn't want DNS enforcing this any more than I want Home Depot on the hook if murderer uses a hammer he bought there to kill someone.
> You and the other hardware stores can't legitimately claim innocence when you are part of a chain that facilitates crime
It's only wrong if you take the problem as stated at face value. But if you look past the declared goals into the real desire - to censor the internet - then it all falls into place and makes total sense. Copyright and think-of-the-children are two bulletproof ways to achieve censorship and I strongly believe that in the end the censors will prevail. I'm coming from a somewhat totalitarian country with extrajudicial internet censorship and let me tell you, sufficiently brainwashed people are all in favor of it.
That example sounds like an extreme strawman but really the concept is similar: the government has identified an organization that is performing an illegal action and asking the DNS provider to stop aiding them.
We can call it “censorship” all day long but society has agreed on that action being illegal. Copyright infringement is illegal, and if someone on this website believes that it should be legal, I think that person is likely a hypocrite for working in the software industry (which would evaporate without copyright law).
If we disagree with the law we should contact our representatives and organize lobbying groups to change the law.
It’s unfortunate that you live in a totalitarian government, but France/Germany ain’t that. The totalitarian government example is somewhat irrelevant to DNS, anyway. A totalitarian government can control what DNS servers you are using. The only reason this issue came up is because it exists in a liberal society with a functioning court system.
Either way, there really aren’t any governments that agree to the idea that abolishing copyright law makes legal sense. Maybe North Korea? But in North Korea 100% of media is controlled by the state so the concept of copyright doesn’t apply to them. There are probably more countries that legalize hard drugs, prostitution, and/or guns than countries that legalize copyright infringement. Why is that? Because a huge amount of critically important industries crucial to the economy of most countries depends on an orderly and fair approach to copyright.
If you think that couldn't happen, I have many bridges for sale.
Quad9 was in a civil case against a private litigant. It’s not even criminal court. It’s another private organization that is bringing a grievance to them and a mediator (the court) ruled against Quad9.
It just isn’t the same as censorship.
It isn't even the government who is coming down with a centralized banhammer telling Quad9 not to serve these DNS records.
It's actually a private company who came to civil court with claims that a different private company (Quad9) was harming them.
In this case, the government's only role is as a mediator and judge of the law for a dispute between two parties.
> the DNS is the wrong place to try to attack that problem
DNS is the wrong place to do censorship, for actual censorship you need to talk to the hosting providers and the ISP. But by now those are hardened.Censoring DNS does not prevent you from getting the content it only prevents you from finding the host based on their name. You can still type the IP and it will connect. Same as a phone number, you can still call the dealer if the number is not in the yellow pages, you just need to find another way to find their number (ask chatgpt or a friend).
You probably wanted to make a top comment with that, not reply to mine. I was quoting the original author.
> You can still type the IP and it will connect
No. Not in the modern internet, no.
> not reply to mine
No, I am responding to that quote and your claim that their real desire is to "to censor the internet". I am saying that if that is indeed their desire DNS is still the wrong place to do that. > No. Not in the modern internet, no.
Can you elaborate? As far as I understand DNS is address lookup, so IP address retrieval. If you know the IP you can connect without DNS involved. Therefore not really censoring anything by censoring DNS responses.This would only work in case there is just a single web site on the IP address and it's served by an ancient http server with the said site being the default one.
Hardly any site today works that way.
Here, "rightsholders" have huge power for two reasons:
- historically we have the "exception culturelle", which means that rightsholders can obtain almost anything they want just by pretending that not giving them will harm our culture and thus what makes our country "so great"
- like almost everywhere, most of the rightsholders are actually a few billionaires that fund politicians and threaten to leave the country if they don't get their way
Add to that the fact that most of our lawmakers have absolutely now knowledge about tech, so they either do absolutely stupid things by themselves, or they do what their patrons tell them to doThat's why:
- we have the HADOPI law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HADOPI_law that wasted millions of public funding in achieving absolutely nothing
- we have to pay a tax to fund rightsholders on every storage medium we buy https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/R%C3%A9mun%C3%A9ration_pour_copie_priv%C3%A9e#France
- more recently, a proposal to tax every Gb of data sent to the Internet has been made https://finance.yahoo.com/economy/policy/articles/france-approves-proposal-0-055-161418750.html
And more broadly, citizens don't care about those things.We are in a Presidential campaign right now, billionaires controlled media have been hard at work convincing many that all that is wrong in the country and in their lives has a single cause: immigration.
So we are more than likely going elect a right-wing President in spring, and, to the surprise of no one, our liberties is going to be the last of their concerns, while doing everything their billionaires patrons will tell them to do, including closing in on the Internet.
Right up there with both Labour and Tories pushing this nanny state "age verification" on to us. Which Big Tech are actually lobbying for I should add. We can thank Zuck showering politicians in money for age verification.
I wonder if Quad9 failed to argue they don't have the technical capability to do blocking. I think that's the most effective form of pushback against an arbitrary court order. As a programmer we think "yeah I guess I could program that, so I tell the judge I have the capability" but the more robust legal perspective is "I didn't already program that, so I tell the judge I don't have the capability, will you order us to develop the capability?" Being ordered to develop a capability is going to be a higher legal bar than being ordered to use one you have.
That calculus only changes if the mechanism creates shared pain ... specifically, if politicians themselves get caught in the crossfire. If foreign jurisdictions begin ordering DNS blocks on European political figures' domains for violating local speech or defamation laws, and providers simply comply to avoid legal liability, the precedent suddenly becomes a problem for the people writing the laws.
On a more practical note, I wonder how thoroughly the legal surface area here has been mapped out. Has anyone pointed frontier models at the French legal code to exhaustively search for compliance loopholes or jurisdictional edge cases?
Spotify, Apple Music etc. nowadays thrive. Netflix briefly thrived, until these behemoths decided to start greedly gating this content as "exclusives".
In my opinion they're abusing the intellectual property system to their own ends. Technology has advanced how society benefits from intellectual property and they're trying to hold us back.
Stop being vague. CF, will you commit to also withdrawing from impacted countries if the ruling goes against you?
Right. But of all companies it seems that Cloudflare has the best track record of fighting the governments for this exact reason, so I feel they're not going to let us down here as well.
Making your enemy take the first action can be strategic for optics. Consider "Google bans Italy" vs "Italy bans Google", who looks better in each scenario?
This French ruling doesn't stop piracy. It will drive reputable providers out, undermine privacy and push users towards less transparent alternatives...
The irony? The judge might go home and use an ISP that collects and potentially monetises their DNS. That's their choice. But why should everyone else lose the freedom to choose a privacy-respecting alternative?
We can't expect every judge to become a network engineer. But we should expect them to understand the consequences of their decisions.
The internet routes around this nonsense. Unfortunately, everydayy users pay the price.
Hypocrites.
But eventually this behavior is going to backfire for everyone when Section 230 has to be reduced to account for it.
Small content providers (a group that I am a member of, but I doubt that you are) already have had their revenue slashed due to LLM training off them, then providing the results to end-users for profit.
> But eventually this behavior is going to backfire for everyone when Section 230 has to be reduced to account for it.
You are very confused; section 230 is for hosters. DNS providers typically don't also host any pirated material. If they do, you can go after them as hosters, not as DNS providers.
I don't see how this is relevant to the discussion.
Open DNS resolvers are a magnet for shenanigans like DDOS amplification attacks etc so best left up to the experts.
However there's easy to use software that your Linux nerd friend can set up, which is "unbound". It pretty much works out of the box. Enable the service, point your DNS server to 127.0.0.1.
The root zone file also updates slowly, and you can download it from IANA and host it yourself.
Is it really?
> Quad9’s announcement may serve as a wake-up call to rightsholders and policymakers
They aren't asleep.
The Internet has eaten the world and everyone is there. All the people are there.
Holding up the idea that all of its infra must be "neutral" like a road and pass through everything doesn't work when everyone is there.
For a stable world, the majority needs to be steered away from the most troublesome things in ways they do not comprehend or notice, because trying to convince them that they probably shouldn't do something is an exercise in futility.
Doing this on a DNS level is good, actually, precisely because it is so easy to bypass by people that matter and are more lucid, open to reason, etc.
Of course, providers don't like that. And there are risks like slippery slopes and all, but I do not see an alternative to this? I do see alternatives, but their either do not achieve what needs to be achieved or are actually worse.
The dream of the Internet is dead. Now we have something else. The sooner we accept that, the sooner we can start coming up with new and better dreams that ideally do not die the same death.
The 'we know whats best for you and block you from ever seeing the rest' parenting / condescending approach. The other is freedom, stretched all the way to anarchy. Where each falls is pretty unique, I think both positions are easily defensible even if not objectively.
I am in both / neither, as a parent of 2 small kids I simply don't expose kids to internet in same way I don't expose them to say pornography. But I believe as adults they should not be restricted in such things and they should choose on their own what they want to do (aka freedom). Even if it may end up being (self)destructive behavior.
And back to original topic - France is a far cry from original 'liberte, egalite, fraternite' motto. Liberte is a joke as folks experienced during covid lockdowns (ie severe punishments if one went more than 1km from their home ie on a lonely hike, I guess around 1.5km viruses multiplied exponentially due to vast cosmic energies or something), egalite in such class society I won't even bother to tackle and fraternite falls apart with each national strike where few individuals make little hell for everybody else and demand more money (since its always about money, while keeping things like massive corruption and semi-dysfunctional state aparatus dragging whole economy down fully intact).
I am nor surprised they withdraw. Its a highly ossified society where big parts think they can force reality of economy, markets or just pure numbers to bend according to their wishes (for absurd job safety, massive very early retirement and general lack of 'agility' of society to massive changes that are coming whether they like it or not).
The difficulty with that is that the cut-off of "adult" is basically arbitrary and does not actually take ones capabilities into account. Not just regarding hurting themselves or others, but _especially_ hurting the bigger systems around them.
It also _needs_ to be this arbitrary cut-off, because any other option will be even worse. But that means that it is fiction, and fiction to a degree that might be harmful and needs extra handling.
That extra handling then looks like boundaries that are invisible to some (through being super easy to bypass) while opaque to others. So you effectively introduce use-case-specific additional qualifiers for the state of "adult".
I like that, because it is easier to target and modulate, and has much fewer downsides than changing the main definition, while also implementing the protections for the system that are necessary to implement.
I wouldn't frame it as paternalism or "set of morals" or anything like that though. That's an emotional layer that detracts from the systemic perspective this is supposed to be viewed through.
I don't see how that follows? Everyone's on the road too, and it seems to work best to keep those neutral?
Roads are then governed by strict rules and you lose your access to those if you do not comply.
Meaning that roads (just like all shared infrastructure) are already a state-filtered thing.
The filters are just calibrated sensibly, meaning that your first thought was not "they're policed and I am oppressed" but "huh, but roads are free, actually?"
__
I did feed this exchange into gemini after the fact and it painted this nice picture that I think might be helpful to better convey what I am trying to convey:
> Actual freedom on a highway would mean dodging uninspected, brake-less, 10-ton vehicles driven by 12-year-olds at 150 miles per hour. That would be terrifying.
> What the user calls "freedom" is actually just a highly restrictive environment where the restrictions perfectly align with his personal habits. Because the user doesn't want to drive a homemade tank drunk at 150mph, he never hits the invisible wall of state friction. Therefore, he assumes the wall doesn't exist.
Is this a joke? The road is full of non-legal vehicles piloted by people without licenses and insurance, in fact it's so common that I have insurance to cover people who are uninsured.
Seriously, look up the stats:
e.g.
The Insurance Research Council’s latest estimate puts the national rate (of uninsured drivers) at 15.4 percent of motorists in 2023, more than one in seven.
Virginia and Pennsylvania report 12%-19% of all cars are driven while failing inspections.
(They sort-of can, of course - modal filters are a thing. But neutral roads seem to work just fine, too. Of course, we do have other methods of policing who uses them, but like in the DNS case, they do still get used for crime. We accept that.)
this is satire, no?
To then have the "great idea" of reducing friction, because friction is bad, to then repeat the cycle all over again.
We live in a democracy. It is the duty of every one of us to face things for what they are. The whole safety thing that democracy gives us grew out of people facing reality. If we steer away from that it will be highjacked by people using the fears to control how you vote. We need brave people with agency. Not people that hide and get manipulated.
Showing 400 of 417. Read the rest on Hacker News
Comments are loaded live from Hacker News and are not stored by Mid or Real.