863 points | 2d ago | Discuss on Hacker News | Back to Radar
They make money from ads.
I think with trials involving experimental life saving treatment for terminal illnesses, doing things like control groups and placebos isn't considered particularly ethical, since you'd be giving false hope to someone who is knocking on death's door.
Although not 100%, almost all terminal patients will die. If you select your test group well so they are very likely to die, then you improve the information you get from the test, favor the class of patients who are most likely to benefit from the treatment and least likely to be harmed by it overall.
If that does happen, then I hope the answer is “nothing”. I know it’s been done a couple of times.
Ethically it's also dodgy.
You'll end up with bad science.
Btw I think it might be just as cruel to give medications to people that sometimes might not help much or at all (after all it's testing!), and that makes them suffer lots of side effects.
The typical approach for phase I trials (where there’s no placebo arm, note) is instead to select patients who have somehow exhausted all standard available treatment options. However, there is often a requirement that trial subjects aren’t as close to death as you propose, as the trial needs to observe patients for safety events as much as possible, even in cases where they aren’t receiving much benefit.
It’s also worth noting that a placebo arm is exceptionally uncommon in oncology trials: you almost always test an investigational agent against some sort of active standard of care treatment.
The idea that you can't otherwise avoid death means all other factors won't have much, or any effect, on the outcome.
Trouble is, there are plenty of examples of drugs which look really good in small single-arm cohorts, but whose promise doesn't hold up under the scrutiny of larger, randomised trials - perhaps because of dumb luck, or because (deliberately or not) the patients selected for the smaller trial were especially likely to respond for some reason, or because the smaller group was treated in especially good hospitals, etc.
So we already do what (I think) you're suggesting, the regulators even support it sometimes, but there can be problems when it is done.
What's going to come next is a randomized case-control trial to show there's a benefit.
In the mean time, here's 25 clinical trials for oncolytic viral therapies for pancreatic cancer:
https://clinicaltrials.gov/search?cond=Pancreatic%20Cancer&i...
And here's a review article on the general concept from the lead physician-researcher in this article:
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6186423/
Adenoviruses are very easy to make with custom contents, and are used for many many purposes. However they rarely make it all the way to become a therapy in practice.
It's always fascinating what hits the front page of HN when it comes to bio!
The contact there is Edward Greeno, the same oncologist named in UMN's coverage: https://discoverymag.umn.edu/stories/when-cancer-therapy-goe...
I think they're hit with reductions in staff and have to do stupid s* like replace all occurances of AI with SI at the same time. It's showing.
This general discussion of the human virome mentions Newcastle disease and Reovirus:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=SbvAaDN1bpE
A full episode followed on a biologist who injected her tumor with Measles:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=0NY2gAftzJE
Edit: The main article identifies an adenovirus that has been modified to replicate primarily in cancerous cells.
"The only cancer-killing virus that has been approved by the Food and Drug Administration in the US is T-VEC, a genetically modified herpes simplex virus that is injected directly into melanoma tumours, causing the cells to rupture and die."
nature is metal
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oncolytic_virus
"In one case report published in 2024, a scientist Beata Halassy treated her own stage 3 breast cancer using an Edmonston-Zagreb measles vaccine strain (MeV) and then a vesicular stomatitis virus Indiana strain (VSV), both prepared in her own laboratory, in combination with trastuzumab. While the treatment was successful and self-experimentation has a long history in science, the decision to publish the case report attracted controversy due to the unapproved nature of the viral agents and treatment protocol used."
Very early results, but it's exciting stuff. I am less confident in this specific trial working out than I am in some therapies in this field making significant progress in the next few years. (As usual, I am reminded how terribly slow research is for people that need treatments now.)
For the next few months, there was a roller coaster of hearing about his new treatments, sometimes seeming effective where we would convince ourselves that he's going to get better, only for him to take a turn for the worse. This kept happening until, of course, he died. I was sad he was dead but the combination of the cancer and the chemo seemed really miserable so I was at least happy he wasn't in pain anymore.
This happened around the time Patrick Swayze died from pancreatic cancer, and a bit before Steve Jobs, and it was at least a little reassuring that this disease didn't spare even obscenely wealthy people. I hope we figure out better treatments for it, and this seems promising.
[1] At least when caught late, which it often is and was for him.
The earlier one's CBT is blocked, the better, as it results in earlier diagnosis.
Jobs had a PanNET tumor[0]. That's the pancreatic cancer you "want". The survival rates are incomparable (iirc localized PanNET survival rate is around 95%!). Jobs chose woowoo bullshit over science, until it was too late. With his money he would have almost certainly been in the surviving group.
Edit to add: Generally when people refer to "pancreatic cancer", they are almost exclusively referring to Adenocarcinoma - the deadly one. That's what Swayze had.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pancreatic_neuroendocrine_tumo...
If you ever find yourself in the situation you'll quickly realise it's a catch-22. You might refuse the deeply unpleasant treatment then question whether you could have survived if you had taken it. Or you could get the treatment, and die anyway with much more pain and suffering, possibly drawn out over more time, all the time being a burden on those you love.
If you've never been there yourself or with someone you love it might be hard to understand. But at least try to understand you don't know all the details of someone else's decision, even if they're a public figure.
Surprisingly often than not its not the case, there are egos, hubris, unresolved childhood issues making folks behave like a child despite building vast corporations from zero or achieving other big successes. I think everybody can imagine a name or two.
https://www.gawkerarchives.com/5849543/harvard-cancer-expert...
https://www.latimes.com/health/la-xpm-2011-oct-20-la-heb-ste...
Some people, when diagnosed with a deadly disease have the attitude of just letting it run its course, preferring to enjoy what's left of their life rather than trying to prolong it at the cost of much suffering. But it doesn't look like that for Steve Jobs. He tried to do something, just not the thing that works, and after realizing that he went back to the procedure he initially refused.
To me, it is a mistake, I can't think of a justification other than that people sometimes make mistakes, and some mistakes are deadly. Refusing unpleasant treatment with the understanding that you may die sooner is not a mistake, it is a choice, going for an unproven alternative treatment only to go back to the regular (unpleasant) treatment once things predictably get worse is a mistake.
(and sure, in Jobs' time those studies might not be common knowledge or may not have existed yet. I don't have links on hand. The most famous one is probably CARET and that was maybe 2003/4ish, but it was only about lung cancer, so overall people still believed in carotene.)
> ...it was at least a little reassuring that this disease didn't spare even obscenely wealthy people.
The obscenely wealthy people eat mostly the same food as obscenely unwealthy people do. From [1], one can conclude that it goes for 3000 years now, probably longer.[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uncd7SvT94c (pharaohs eat same food as the lower classes of society, judging from the teeth wear and decay)
Gout, a illness of the royals, is associated with prediabetic state, which is "achieved" through elevated consumption of carbohydrates.
Another anecdote: Darwin was from a wealthy family and sick af. In that context I read that the wealthy ate lots of organ meat, which the commoners didn't, and as a result they had higher incidences of some chronic diseases. (I'm not saying this is proven, but eating the body's sewage organs probably isn't the greatest idea.)
Unwealthy people (obscenely unwealthy usually means indigent) can only afford ultraprocessed junk if they don't have any time to spare.
Full bio food including spices and all other ingredients, only wild shrimps or salmon caught far from mainland? Replace sweeteners with sugar with various plant-based alternatives that have much lower carbs and have small insulin spike? Rich folks have 0 reasons to ever eat any product you can buy in any retail store including premium lines, what can be created on spot is always much better in taste. Of course it can go the other way - if one focuses purely on taste then humongous amounts of ie butter are used for gravies for example.
Its true we saw even winning US presidency resulted in basic mcd meal celebration in private jet (I guess for media how those billionaires were actually commoners from the crowd).
So rich have way more options, its completely up to them how much they lean into it. With enough cash you can eat anything you want, even eating mangoes that were picked up in the jungle 5h ago 5000km away. And anybody who had fresh mango on spot can attest its exquisite experience that cannot be simply bought from afar regardless of money (so are also otherwise rather bland food like bananas). My parents grow ie carrots that have 10x the taste of even most expensive bio ones we can get in premium shops here in Switzerland or neighboring France, and same goes for most food.
> So rich have way more options, its completely up to them how much they lean into it.
Yes, they have much more options. Yes, the question is how much would they lean into it.This Youtube channel has videos of his owner eating at many haute cuisine restaurants, including three-Michelin-starred ones: https://www.youtube.com/@HarrisonWebb97/videos
The calories and amino acids profiles of haute cuisine food presented there are not all that healthy. At least, not all the time, from what I was able to gather. These profiles are about at same level as, I do not know, something like street fast food.
If rich ones do not control everything and anything their chefs do, chefs will change their cooking to what they were trained for. And in case of multiple-Michelin-starred-restaurant-trained chef, it will be multiple-Michelin-starred-restaurant food, only slightly (in most important regards) different from street fast food.
Also, with increasingly two people in a household both busy working full time, there's is indeed not a lot of time to prepare meals from actual fresh ingredients.
Is there a "label" for this type of AI slop writing? I see it A LOT in most of my sessions with the format:
[Some positive assertion of something that is], not [something that is not/doesn't hold].
That's a sure sign of something being AI written, and I battle to make AIs avoid it because it doesn't add anything of value.
Misdiagnosis is very common with pancreatic cancer, it seems. My mum was complaining about stomach pains and sickness for a long time before they finally tested her for pancreatic cancer; before that, they had all sorts of theories about what it was, including tropical sprue. By the time she knew it was cancer, she was stage 4 with months to live. Thankfully, chemo kept her alive just long enough to meet her grandson, and also for assisted dying laws that had just passed in Victoria, Australia.
Hope that one day no one else has to go through what we did.
At a bare minimum, you will need to have a mass large enough to be seen on CT scan, and then an endoscopic biopsy (among GI scopes, the endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography or ERCP is one of the most difficult). And even that may not get enough tissue for a diagnosis.
So, yeah, failure to diagnose it is common - largely because it's almost impossible to diagnose early. I'm a doctor. We feel sick when these things happen. It's horrible for our patients.
The NIH says more than half of cancer deaths come from types of cancer that lack established screening tests. This is just scary stuff. At a certain point, blaming doctors and hospitals doesn't make sense. We just don't have the technology for easy detection of many cancers and by the time doctors figure it out, the disease has to be advanced enough to be detected by them. That advanced stage often means treatment is difficult or impossible.
I think our future will be tumor markers for early cancer detection. But in the meantime, do your screenings, do risk modification (ie don't smoke or excessively drink). Get to know your family history and if something isn't right with your body, seek medical help and find someone who is willing to listen.
I know it's probably not what you want to hear, but our bodies have a shelf life. The longer we are alive, the higher our cancer risks. Do what your can to screen, but sometimes your genes predispose you to cancers and that's not something we can modify ... atleast right now. Hopefully soon we have a huge breakthrough in true tumor markers that are more accurate and maybe these new mRNA cancer vaccines are the breakthrough we need much like when we got the first Hepatitis C treatments.
--Not a Radiologist or Oncologist, just your local Family Medicine MD and HN Nerd
You will find abnormalities on both. They are likely to be nothing, but having found them, they must be investigated. The investigations are not risk-free because they are necessarily invasive. Bad things happen stochastically: there is always a chance.
You don't. This is the same reasoning why not to check for breast cancer.
You can take multiple measurements and only act when something appears to be getting worse.
Isn't a tumor search the same thing but harder? I would normally assume it's more of a man power thing than anything else... But can we really not do better?
Sure X-rays are carcinogenic, so you can't exactly do a routine full body scan, and teeth are important enough on their own to justify being one of those targets.
But while I lack the clinical expertise, having worked on the medical device side and with hospital systems like Epic (and systems vastly worse than Epic). I can't help but cynically assume the real issue is that hospital systems are only finally catching up to the databases of 2005, and any such data collection would never realistically increase patient outcomes because the systems for such a thing would be too fragmented/shit to work with. Data collection is pointless if you can't actually utilize it.
For some perspective, this is the "standardized" way data is moved around in medical contexts: https://www.cdisc.org/standards/data-exchange
Despite the immense complexity in even supporting it, especially with them changing it randomly every few years, the protocol and data formats are filled with capabilities allowing for "exceptions" to the protocol and custom fields. Which in practice means... not actually standized, and so therefore they all become a glorified spread sheet with key values, often no better than hand written notes. And that's all just the tip of the iceberg!
Meanwhile dental care is basically a separate system entirely. Therefore the focus makes it easier to standardize and track things.
Check how much MRI scan does cost. Many not-super-rich countries have total amount of MRI devices below 10, I know mine does. CT scan is not that cheaper and gives 10-500x radiation dose of a single X-ray, definitely not something one should be doing regularly especially chest/head area where most of tumors happen. You will literally create cancer out of thin air.
> That’s investigating.
Not by your own definition.
MRI is as close to zero risk as you can get. It's also slow, expensive, and relatively limited in capacity.
‘Cancer of unknown origin’ is a grim diagnosis.
When I tried to research I very quickly realized there is really nothing you can do. Maybe this does give people hope!
Ten years later, and I've decided it's time to read the last book she ever gave me.
I really hope we'll see a cure for this disease soon.
That disease is the absolute worst and I'm really happy to see this progress.
Sorry for your loss. My mom passed from pancreatic cancer in the spring of this year. If the grief decay continues at this linear rate I'm afraid I'll be saying the same thing in ten years.
And totally agree about these giving hope. Especially for me and the rest of her lineage.
One of the more helpful things I saw somewhere was something along the lines of accepting each loss as its own thing. Your relationship with your father may have similar intensity as a spouse, but it's a different thing. The things you deal with on one situation may not matter in another, and so on.
I’ve had digestive problems for years. But recently, it’s gotten worse. Blood tests, urine+stool tests, and a colonoscopy all came back normal. Lately, I’ve been experiencing severe pain when lying down and can only sleep sitting up.
My doctor thinks it might be a mechanical issue with my spine and told me to just take ibuprofen for the pain and inflammation.
The problem with abdominal pain is that it’s impossible for me to tell which organ the pain is coming from. Kidney? Liver? Intestine? Spine? It's very frightening and I don't know what to do.
Even when symptoms are noticed, most symptoms that people have can be any one of a number of things. Go look for constipation, then look up each symptom individually and see what all it can map to. Pretty much every symptom of the very common constipation is also the only symptom you'll see of heart attack, liver cancer, liver disease, appendicitis, pancreatic cancer, pretty much anything goes wrong in the rib cage...
Spine would be the only exception. I don't think Spine ever manifests quite that way. On the other hand, my leg pain turned out to be a tumor on the spine. Thankfully it wasn't cancer.
Really, the best advice I can get is pay attention to what you feel like normally. If something's unusual, get to a doctor. Most people who go to the ER for a heart attack symptom are not having a heart attack. We could save a lot of lives, and I mean a lot of lives, if more people would be going to the emergency room for heart attack symptoms even though most people who don't go to the ER for such symptoms are correct they're not having a heart attack and don't need to be there.
Could be a good next step for you.
The first warning sign for her was jaundice, so she took on a kind of sallow (yellow/brown) complexion. However, looking back I noticed that before diagnosis, and never connected it.
Two other things which may signal trouble are energy crashes and weight fluctuations. I know two people who had trouble with this recently. In one case, it turned out to be thyroid cancer, and he had to push for diagnosis, and nag the medics to get something done. He seems to be okay now (touch wood), but take note of this.
I agree about abdominal pain. Hard to know what causes it. Back and even chest pain don't always stem from expected causes. (People assume chest pain is heart trouble. It can be but there are other things.)
So, maybe mention it to your doctor? It's probably not that but may be an option.
But cancer care is always improving, so hopefully less and less people have to experience this.
In her 50s. Kept relatively healthy for the previous 30 years. Misdiagnosed repeatedly by a trusted GP. Had so much life to live. It was so unfair.
News like this is so heartening.
Try not to blame the GP. Misdiagnosis is the norm, and exactly why survival stats are so dismal.
Pancreatic cancer is the prototypical "zebra disease" [1] -- it's so rare that it would be irresponsible to go looking for it before ruling out all of the more common things it resembles.
[1] "When you hear hoofbeats, think horses, not zebras."
The link also says that it's only 3.2% of all cancer diagnoses. So even if you limit yourself to cancer, it's rare.
[1] Please also look up the difference between "lifetime risk of X", and "chance that the patient sitting in front of me has X at time T". They're not the same.
It can be frustrating to not know the true cause of the symptoms, but only a cure (this trial seems to show promise) will offer any real hope.
I dread pancreatic cancer and dementia more than other diseases.
Pancreatic cancer feels like a horrible fate: long enough to contemplate your own mortality and see the end with no real hope of avoiding your fate.
I do know someone who survived a Whipple and lived for a decade after (he was a health fanatic, and paid careful attention to his body, so it was detected early because he didn't let go till he got a diagnosis); succumbing to an unrelated disease, but I hope that there's more hope for people than is currently the case.
With all that misdiagnosis data, maybe docs can start parallel cancer tests, too.
I can't stop thinking whenever I come across new cancer-related research: if these successes had been achieved sooner, maybe Steve Jobs could have been saved.
In the same way, the doctors went down a lot of different paths before a later CT scan picked up the mass on the pancreas which has also spread to other organs.
While two weeks was short, she did struggle and I'm glad she didn't have to endure it for too long. I'm not sure life will ever feel the same again but I am learning to cope with the loss as the weeks go by.
Sorry for your loss and all the others who have commented.
Notice that I said sometimes above. Sometimes the earlier we catch it, the earlier we treat it, the better. But sometimes not. See your doctor and hope your doctor is up with the latest research.
If someone could come up with a good way to catch before it starts spreading, that would be even better, but I'm not aware of any progress on that.
'High risk' in this case means someone who has had 2 relatives develop the disease - otherwise it's not recommended due to the risk of false positives and everything that comes with that.
I only know all this because my mother died of the disease.
Pancreatic is ‘special’ in that there’s space around the organ so a tumor can grow without causing local symptoms. (In contrast, for a change in bowel habit; a brain tumor might cause seizures).
Then you have screening, which is hard to do at scale, due to cost, risks of the screening techniques (eg radiation exposure, or invasiveness of the test itself), limited available testing facilities, and the problems caused by irrelevant or false positive findings generated when an imperfect test is applied at population scale.
A simple blood test would be great, and there are people working on things that might ultimately result in this, but we’re not there yet, afaik.
It doesn't get around the problem of incidental findings, though. As in: the scan shows something abnormal but non-specific somewhere. Can you rule out cancer? Not 100% from just the scan. So this causes stress for the patient, and probably requires further investigations, which have their own costs, stress, and risks attached. And ultimately many of these findings won't be cancer or anything else actionable - meaning that in hindsight, the cost/stress/risk was for no benefit.
So when scaling a test up to a population scale, you need to start considering all of these factors and have numbers to support that, overall, it will result in a net positive, and that overall, it's cost-effective at saving lives.
Cancers like leukemia, melanoma, lymphoma and conditions like aplastic anemia, immune, autoimmune disorders can be treated by infusing the patient with compatible bone marrow stem cells from a donor. Finding a compatible donor can be difficult, on average in the general population its on the order of 1:10,000 to find a match. For that reason there's a registry that people can submit a cheek swab to. In my case I joined the registry about 15 years ago when someone in my extended friend circle had leukemia. A swab drive was organized to find her a donor, which eventually happened and she wound up beating it. I didn't match her but a few years ago I matched another patient and wound up donating.
In the US the registry is National Marrow Donor Program. Signup on their website and they will send you a free swab kit.
It will probably take my lifetime or more to make more than incremental progress on this disease, but I welcome every step.
I felt my missing him was odd as he didn't die that young. But reading all these stories of people who lost parents or relatives to pancreatic cancer and seeing how much they miss them years later... maybe it's normal to miss a parent even if their time had come.
Parents have such an impact on their children.
The mix of stories and the way they are discussed in this thread are a good reminder for why we all come here.
These news about treatments are good. But one thing that gives me pause is that, even if we had a technical pipeline that would be able to produce a cure for each cancer, there are still lots and lots of care issues: diagnosis that are only produced after the patient has been going to the hospital for half a year. Long wait times for CT scans. Long wait times for biopsy results. Long wait times for access to a medication. Wait times for surgery. And all of it is expensive as hell.
Good as it is, I don't think the medical system as it is today has the proportions and efficiencies needed to beat cancer for one in four people.
On the other hand: remembering that you’ll die one day and that that day might come quicker than you’d expect helps to get priorities right in life.
https://www.theguardian.com/society/2026/nov/20/pill-pancrea...
Comments are loaded live from Hacker News and are not stored by Mid or Real.
DivingForGold 2d ago on HN
https://www.newscientist.com/article/2528235-pancreatic-canc...
ksd482 2d ago on HN
_Microft 2d ago on HN
HedonicEscal8r 2d ago on HN